tion, suspicion and hatred. Economically, politically and socially they have been known only as aliens.
This hard lot has forced the growth in the Jews of certain secondary traits by which they have been marked for dislike and contempt. Their resistance has necessarily ben pl:ant rather than bold; they have stood their ground by seeming to give way. They have developed, as is well known, extraordinary resourcefulness, an unparalleled ability to make the best of any situation. In a clever and deliciously ironical paper on “The Solution of the Jewish Question,” Dr. Joseph Jacobs has explained the unpopularity of the Jew as due to his immoderate cleverness. I cannot resist the temptation to quote a para- eranh:
““ihe essence of the world’s opinion of us I took to be that a Jew is never to be found unarmed. ‘You can never best a Jew,’ is the feeling of les autres. And not alone ıs the Jew not to be bested, but he is certain to be the conqueror in any struggle, not so much by superiority of power, as by the persistent use of it. And this is not all. The Jew carries the conflict of life into affairs where there should be no conflict. He converses on politics, the theatre, a friend’s character, or what not; he is never content unless he comes off victor, or at least has the last word. ‘If you want to stop a Jew’s talk’, a friend once said to me, ‘agree with all he says; without the stimulus of conflict he cannot continue’ All this leaves an unpleasant flavor with it; there is no repose in the relation of Jews to others. Thus thinking, I saw my way to a remedy. We must change all this. Let us now and then give way. Let us be content at times to be second best in a bargain, a competition or a conversation; or, still better, let us cease at times to bargain, compete, or polemicise at all. We have waged the fight long and bravely; let us put aside our arms for a while and meet our whilom enemies in friendly converse. I thought of proposing a new festival, a kind of All Fools’ Day for Judaism, on which every Jew should trv as hard to lose some prize in the battle of life as he now does to win it. The experiences of a few anniversaries would convince Jews of the wisdom of my advice, and the solution of the Jewish Question would seem at hand.”
III.
Now let us put the two sides of our picture together. In this dualism I believe we shall find the most general and most striking characteristic of the Jew as he is to-day. He does not seem to be what he is. He does not con-
duct himself in the world according to his convictions, and faith; he does not represent himself. In other words, there are no Jewish manners in the more significant sense of that term. What I mean may be set forth more clearly if I make use of several illustrations.. The perfection of Greek life lies largely in its unity and consistencey. You can study it on any side, and you will be brought in the end to the same underlying conception. Greek art, Greek literature, Greek political institutions, Greek customs and manners are all charged with the same spirit. In bearing, posture, forms of address, and gesture, the Greek appears to be what he is. In other words, represents himself. It is this that marks the best manhood of any type or age. The chivalry of the Middle Ages was neither a matter of secret conviction nor a matter of outward expression, but its very essence consisted in its being both. It was a manner of expressing inner convictions, and an inner conviction which grounded and supported a mode of life. It is through such a unity and harmony of life that ideas enter into history. The separation of expression and idea cannot fail to injure both. Without being rightly related to ideas, manners are accidental or vulgar, like the idioms and standards of the street when divorced from their background in tradition and national sentiment. Ideas without expression become infected with a sort of unwholesomeness. In the present case I think it may be fairly said that Jewish ideas have suffered greatiy through lack of ventilation. They have not enjoyed enough sunshine, and as a consequence have not had a normal growth. Meanwhile, the world moves on to confirm the divorce of ideas from expression. If one is to act at all, one must act in the present; and when ideas become antiquated, they become irrelevant. To me, then, leaving aside the actual distress which this unfortunate people ’still suffer, the most deplorable element in the present situation of Judaism is this lack of wholeness, of bold and sincere lıving. The modern Jew coming into contact with the world finds that the world knows nothing about his ideals. And he lacks the gift of utterance, he cannot communicate them, translate them into terms of common intercourse. Yet, he finds in modern institutinns