EDITORIAL PAGE.
sufferers. Already the American Jewish Committee has forestalled a popular appeal by transferring its Kishineff money to Roumania. Was that done in order to avoid an encounter with public opinion? The San Francisco appeal did not prove very successful in testing the strength of the position of that Committee. Probably had another collection been made, our brethren would have given liberally. They always give liberally when the red track of Jewish blood is moistened. But when will they give to forestall the pogroms that have become such common incidents in Jewish life?
JUDAISM AND HEBRAISM.
There is a new rabbi in Boston. His name is Wolf Margolis and he comes from Grodno. His "orthodoxy" is absolute. He will hear of nothing save the utmost punctilitiousness in ritual and dogma. He anathematizes Zionism because it seeks to forestall the Messiah and because it breaks the rigidity of some eighty or ninety year old traditions. He is very canny and Jesuitical.
There is also an ancient rabbi in Boston. His names is Charles Fleischer and he comes from Cincinnati. His "reform" is absolute. He will hear of nothing save the utmost anarchy in ritual and dogma. He anathematizes Zionism because it seeks to re-Judaize the Jew and because it selects an inherited ideal and does not ape the "religious" fads he is devoted to. He is very very much the reverse of canny and Jesuitical. Those who live in his town know him as the most adequate representative of the Jewish chameleon.
Both these persons, Wolf Margolis and Charles Fleischer, claim to teach the true and only Judaism. And they are to be counted as ministers of the same identical religion. Each claims that the other is villainously wrong and a traitor to what the religion really is. Their attitudes are so flatly contradictory that neither can be right. As a matter of fact, what each stands for is a gloss and comment on the entity to which they refer, and that gloss and com-
ment is private and belongs to each alone. They are Rabbinists, not Judaists.
What is this thing they destroy? It is a very definite and adequately defined series of attitudes, assumed by a very definite and distinct people toward their God. It is open to betrayal, has been, and is being rabbininized in Grodno and Cincinnati because it has been torn out of its context in the unitary life of a unitary people. To live, it must remain part of the organic whole to which it belongs. A hand cut off from the body becomes a dead hand. A religion also. It is easy to see why professional religionists mourn over the decay of Judaism. Severed from the entirety of the life to which it belongs, it must rot, that is, rabbinize.
The religious attitude is not the only attitude a people is called upon to assume. Tt is one among an organic infinity of them, which express together a single racial unity. The word which means that organic infinity is Hebraism. Hebraism expresses the whole race-nature. Judaism is an element in Ilebraism. If its metabolism is more rapid or slower than that of the other components of the unit, Hebraism, it is diseased and must be cut out. Rabbinism ıs Judaism, sick.
Nothing is so necesasry to the Jews of America, now, as Judaism. Women organize to seek it for themselves and for their children. Men build temples to hold it in, and try to attain it by endowing schools of theology and founding "Hebrew" charities. It is time to learn that the living religion cannot be had except from the whole living culture of the Jews, Hebraism.
Zionism, in our opinion, is the only road to Judaism. Who refuses to take it may rest in peace with his Kohlerisms and Fleischerisms and Margolisisms. The nostrum habit is as common in religion as in medicine, and it involves little more than spiritual insincerity.
Those, however, who are spiritually sincere, know the way to spiritual health and take it. M.
M.