The Maccabaean · Vol. XII, No. 5 · May 1907
193printed page
scan 33 of 52
THE MACCABAEAN.
193

THE MACCABAEAN

A Monthly Magazine under the supervision of the Federation American Zionists. Edited by Louis Lipsky

EDITORIAL PAGES.

UNION AND STRENGTH.

The directors of the I. O. B. B., the Union of the American Hebrew Congregations and the American Jewish Committee, need to be informed of one very pertinent fact: In union is strength, but union never creates strength. The combination of any number of dead organizations will not make one live one. The combination will‘not produce one popular Jewish organization qualified and authorized to spcak for a united Jewry. Until a plan is acted upon, that shall call the Jewish people to elect their representatives to act for them in the matter of national Jewish interests— not vaguely, to represent them as members ° of this or that organization, but specifically for that purpose—all talk of union and harmony in Jewish organizations, is like the futile attempt of a blind man to feel his way along a rocky road. Zionism says to these representatives of the people and leaders of Jewish affairs, “Remove the bandages of pride-.and obstinacy from your eyes, and behold the Jewish people, in whom you must trust, and who are the sources of all Jewish strength.”

THEY HAVE MADE THEIR CHOICE.

Tue Hebrew Union College, through its legal managers, seem to have agreed with Dr. Kohler, and to have decided that a Zionist cannot be a member of the faculty of the college.

It is well that a declaration of policy has been made.

In articles which have appeared in the "Reform Advocate" and the "Jewish Exponent," Dr. Kohler fixes the dogma with which he hopes to burden American Reform Judaism. He claims the wide world for the Jew who "is to fertilize it with his seeds of truth and righteousness until social justice and peace reign everywhere." His liberalism excommunicates any Reform Jew

who denies the mission theory of suffering and dispersion;—the more thoroughly dispersed the better. He will probably extend his anathema to the students of the college and withhold the degree of rabbi from any impertinent theological student who has views as to Jewish nationalism and who denies that the mission theory is worthy of the endorsement of a dignified independent people.

The policy of evasion has been broken, and all who are responsible for the resignations of Profs. Margolis, Malter, and Schloessinger have cast their vote in favor of a synodal edict without the formality of calling a synod.

We waive all question as to the right of Dr. Kohler and the governors of the college to commit Reform Judaism against Zionism without submitting their views to Central Conference of American Rabbis. We waive all inquiries into the truth of the declaration that Reform Judaism finds its historical justihcation in a denial of rationality. Pending endorsement by the Union of American Congregations, they are the trustees of the reform movement in America. If they choose, they may convert the college into a kindergarten for the nursing of anti-Zionists. They may, even now, enact an ex-post-facto law, and repudiate the implied agreement with their students to grant them the rabbinical degree when they have passed through the period of study. They may even expel those students whose enthusiasm, whose thinking, whose lives have made them Zionists. They may separate American Reform Judaism from universal Judaism, and they may attentuate Jewish beliefs to the vanishing point.

But they should know that by such a policy they are converting the Hebrew Union College into a petty, sectarian, dogmatic institution of learning. They are deliberately creating a schism in Jewish re-