The Zionist Observer
Playing with Words
THE other evening a few of us sat together in a cafe. We had come from a discussion of "blue laws" and their effect upon Jews. By sheer perversity, we went a little deeper into the problem. One pointed out that there was a moral point involved when legislation forced a man to decide between his conscience and his needs. In a few minutes we were swimming in very deep waters. Suddenly, one of the debaters, mentally as it were, struck shore with the exclamation: "Well, if you put the situation so, it's a case of persecution."
"Exactly," said another, with a characteristic pursuing of the lips.
The discoverer of the situation rubbed his forehead. "We should not speak of persecution."
He of the pursed lips made a most expressive gesticulation and said curtly: "Why shouldn’t we?”
The other mopped from his forehead an invisible perspiration and repeated: "Why shouldn't we?"
Ever since, "Why shouldn't we," has been ringing in our ears.
Why shouldn't we—what, recognize truths and proclaim them in simple nakedness! We once visited a certain Southern city, and calling on its Rabbi, incidentally asked whether there existed any anti-Jewish prejudice in his historic home city. "Not at all, not at all," he replied. He related how he had participated in various non-Jewish affairs. Presently, still talking to him, but on other subjects, we noticed a fine building and confusing it with some topographical information offered us, pointed to it.
"No, no," said the Rabbi, "that's our new apartment house. Of course they don't admit Jews there."
“Isn’t that persecution?” we hazarded.
"Not at all, not at all! That's social ostracism," was the reply.
The Rabbi was right. Social ostracism is not persecution, because it doesn't force you out— as a rule—only it keeps you out. Of course if you want to form a club or a fraternity, you are not wanted, and you know it—blame yourself for seeking the unattainable. But if you go and live in a street because the houses have a Southern exposure and you can afford such a luxury, then your neighbors, discovering you are a Jew, prepare to move elsewhere. Then you are merely face to face with a beautiful example of "humanitarianism." You may philosophize over that psychological idiocyncracy which permits admiration for the Jew in the abstract and demands, as counterbalance, dislike of him in the concrete. Remember, if your reflections happen to be rather bitter, that the attitude of your neighbors does not strain your possession of equality before the law, by a single hair's breadth—you are not being persecuted—you are simply being snubbed and you suffer from domiciliary ostracism.
Do you think we are playing with words? Not at all! You ought to cultivate a proper sense of perspective. Take a brief course in art in order to understand the exact relationship of "background," "middle distance" and "foreground."
The odds are you began in the background of Iife—vou may be still there. You got out. If not—get out of it. The background exhibits you as "elannish.” In the body social the background is where people “huddle” together and where the community of interest makes them “elannish.” Getting out nf tbe background is not easy. Sometimes, though you have been preparing to get out for months and years, at the moment of migration you are shot forward as thouglı from a catapult— vou land a little ahead of the “middle-distance,” almost on the sacred sands of the
