selves from the influence of the mystics, who gave our ideal a supernatural form, nor from the influence of the universalists, who see in the coming future that Utopian golden age when the wolf and the lamb will actually live together.
In fact, within the last few years numerous pamphlets have appeared written against Zionism. Some of these pamphlets, written by Kautsky, Isgoeff, Uzakoff and Eikerman, have gained quite a popularity.
EEE GE EEE > BundsgsninEn En ine VE Ri In reviewing these pamphlets we must greatly deplore the lack of unity among the Zionist critics. The critics have failed to come to an understanding on the fundamental principles of the questions involved, and they frequently conträdict one another’s views. They themselves cannot agree, whether Jewry represents a nation or not, whether assimilation is desirable or not, whether the creation of a legally assured autonomy is feasible or not, whether Zionism in general is a dangerous movement, or whether there exısts at all a Judennoth. ete.
For the sake of clearness, we shall briefly review each critic of Zionism. We will commence with Kautsky, who speaks mainly of anti-Semitism and proposes assimilation as the proper remedy.
I.
Kautsky believes that the general tendencv of all nationalities is to blend together, even to substituting their national languages by some un’versal language. Let us examine whether such a deduction is logical. National peculiarities are the result of the influence of many factors: the climate, the soil, the flora of that country where a given race first developed itself. Kautsky admits this fact by deriving the psychology of the Jews from the fact that Palestine is a mountainous country; he adds, that the impression of the mountainous origin is preserved in foreign lands; i. e., when transferred to new conditions of soil, climate and social environment. The national character impressed by mother nature is strong and lasts even when the race changes its abode. As long as the old blood is inherited without an alloy of alien blood, or very little of it, so long will the race
preserve its own individuality. Of course, this individuality is already somewhat distorted, and with each generation will under the pressure of new soil and climatic influences, divert from the original type; yet, even under strange skies one can recognize in the pure blooded descendant after many generations the features of his ancestors. Still better are preserved the peculiarities of that race, which always lives in the same country, on the same soil, where it developed itself. This is a direct inference from the proposition that racial peculiarities are the result of the common natural factors.
I am not touching upon the question of how the now existing nationalities were formed and how much of different racial ingredients entered into each of them. I take them as I find them at the time of my appearance in the world, and put to myself the question, what wıll become of them? What is more probable, that the ınhabitants if the Apennine Peninsula will in the future, from generation to generation, continue to live on that peninsular. or that thev will all migrate to another place? And to this, ın my opinion, no other answer is possible, than that the first supposition is more probable, as there is no more apparent cause which would compel the inhabitants of Italy to such a mass emigration. At the present time, it is well known, people often emigrate in search of labor. while on the peninsula and in Sicıly there are large stretches of waste land. suitable for intensive colonization. The emigration js but a small percentage of the population. Kautsky believes that want and hunger will sometime be entirelv abolished. and I also modestly share this belief, but then the cause of emigration will cease even for the smallest part of the population. Consequently. this population on the peninsula will’become more settled than now. Mixed marriages, if they become 'customary, will be contined only to limited areas, but the main bulk of the nation will preserve its racial purity. This will undisputably happen in Russia, France, Scandinavia, etc. There are no cause» to incite the population.