lines, that even after those centres of Jewish life called ghettos were destroyed, the young Jew and Jewess would be able to create positive Jewish religious values.
"He had not only faith in the American Jew, but also did his share toward realizing his dream. He was the one man of the reformed Jewish movement who created something enduring.
"But his great hope in the future has not and could not be justified. With the gradual accession from centres of Jewish energy, Jews were less than ever justifying their separate existence. They were no better and no worse morally than their surroundings, and they were even contributing less than their neighbors to the development of religious thought. They were consequently under present conditions not a priest-people, a community of teachers to the nation, either in actual living or in religious theory."
Dr. Magnes declared that the principle of reform, that is, of development, enunciated most strongly by Isaac M. Wise, is a sound principle. On that basis it is necessary to make another step in advance. This step Dr. Magnes believed to lie in Jewish nationalism, or Zionism, or the creation of a national centre of Jewish energy in Palestine, whereby Jewish ideals might be furthered in all parts of the world.
The speaker said that the Hebrew Union College was the favorite child of Isaac M. Wise. But at the present time, the speaker was very sorry to say, the Hebrew Union College was signing the death warrant of reformed Judaism. It is a curious phenomenon that the reformed Jewish movement, whose very reason for existence was the maintenance of the principle of development in Judaism, should now become ossified and dogmatic and reactionary.
The speaker held that any institution of learning has the right to choose its teachers. But he said that the very principle of development and liberalism upon which the college was founded by Isaac M. Wise is now being endangered. Free and scientific research into Jewish history and literature was now to be stifled, and all subjects were
to be taught not as to the truth in them, but from a preconceived dogmatic point of view. The college had never, as a matter of fact, adopted any dogmatic statement as to its principles, and the men who were brought there to teach had never been interrogated as to their dogmatic fitness. Yet the college, in the opinion of the speaker, had now the right to declare itself openly as favoring one set of dogmas or the other. In this event, however, the Jewish world ought to know that the movement had declared all development to have ceased with it, that the Hebrew Union College is not to be a scientific school of Jewish learning.
Dr. Magnes thought all of this an evidence of the ossification of the reformed movement. which was now without any such broadminded leader as was Isaac M. Wise. Instead of men of real liberalism of spirit, there was being developed an ecclesiastical hierarchy. It was an ironical but apparently natural, development, to find a progressive, forward movement becoming reactionary and retrogressive after the men who were its creators had for the most part passed away. .
Dr. Magnes said that the failure of the reformed movement to impress itself in a most positive way upon Judaism was not due to persons, but rather to historical forces beyond the control of any man.
New Palestine Project
The Palestine Commission is occupying itself with the formation of a Palestine Agicultural Company under limited liabilities to further plantations, horiculture, agriculture, cattle breeding and husbandry in Palestine. The locale of the company is to be in the German capital, and the practical management in Palestine. The present capital is to be £25,000 in shares of £5o, of which ten per cent. is to be had on application. It is proposed to take a long lease of a large farm as a going concern, in the neighborhood of which the company will acquire ground for its own cultivation. Experts, who are conversant with Palestinian conditions. will participate in the financial obligations.