The Maccabaean · Vol. XII, No. 4 · April 1907
158printed page
scan 40 of 52
158
THE MACCABAEAN.

the new light. The president of the B'nai B'rith, in spite of his shortcomings, is groping at some scheme which will permit the B'nai B'rith to get rid of its swaddling clothes. The B'rith Abraham has also shown a willingness to work hand in hand with Zionists.

That day be blessed when all Jews, in whatever form of organization their Jewish affliation may show, recognize their moral and financial obligation to the Jewish national movement. Zionism is bound to strengthen every Jewish organization that gives an opening to its ideas. It is bound to make its membership more earnest, more devoted, and to give them a better idea of the work to be done by every Jew. If the Jewish press opposes Zionism, it need not complain of the lack of support of the Jewish oommunity, for ‘its best interest is bound up with the progress of our movement.

REFORM CONVERTS.

The confession of Prof. Margolis has doubtless been read with some interest by our readers. It is, in effect, a frank statement of past error and of the causes that have led him to declare himself. He deserves credit for his courage.

With the premises and the expression of his altered opinion, there need be no quarrel. The germs of Zionist thought, he declares, have been evident in his scholarly articles; and a more detailed and finished formulation of his articles of faith is promised. What is now obscure will probably be more clearly stated, and we may expect added fervor and less insistence on the religious dilemma when the stammer of the convert becomes the fluent expression of the enthusiast.

But what a flutter in the dove-cotes of reform Judaism his conversion has caused! Leaders of that phase of Jewish religious thought who boast of the mission theory, have become so disagreeably sensitive on Zionism that the deflection of one of their number produces a sort of “brain-storm,” which does not lend itself to scientific investigation. The Zionistic infection of the Hebrew Union College seems to be spreading, and now one can count on the fingers

of one hand the old guard of "Washing- tonian Zionists" who speak for the old mission idea.

Is it not absurd to think that a dozen men, aided by a defunct journal which stilf speaks through its worthy father’s old hat, should attempt to fix the first principles of liberal Jewish thought in religion on the basıs of obsolete notions? Is it not queer that a dozen men will speak in .the name of reform Judaism, when such rabbis as Dr. Bernard Felsenthal, .a pioneer in reform, Dr. Max Heller, Dr. A. M. Radin, Dr. Stephen S. Wise, Dr. J. L. Magnes, Rabbi Max Raisin, Rabbi J. Friedlander, Dr. Max Scholoesinger, Prof. Max Margolis, and a score of other reformers are work- eıs in the Zionist movement? Is itnota bit of impudence for this dozen men to speak as if they and they alone represented the views of a movement which, if it has any merit, first spoke of liberalism and progress in Jewish life, and shunned dogmatism as the bane of Jewish progress?

IMMIGRATION INTO PALESTINE.

Those wiseacres who predict the future of Palestine with the statistical rule in hand, and who therefore do not see an astonishingly large migration to the Holy Land, need not worry about the reply Zionists may make to the figures. It is not to be expected, nor would it be entirely beneficial, if large numbers of Jewish immigrants just now made their way into Palestine. What we have to guard against is a rush in that direction. The invasion of Palestine would mean the complete disarrangement of all plans, and it would introduce anarchy instead of order in the development of the country.

The time since the last Congress has been devoted, so far as the organization is concerned, with plans and suggestions as to the direction improvenient should take. The Palestine Commission has been explicit in its warnings. It does not desire a promis- cuous, pogrom-inspired immigration. It does not want to have. Palestine the immediate haven of refuge for all those forlornı members of our race who have been