The Maccabaean · Vol. XII, No. 4 · April 1907
157printed page
scan 39 of 52

THE MACCABAEAN

A Monthly Magazine under the supervision of the Federation of American Zionists. Edited by LOUIS LIPSKY

EDITORIAL PAGES

April, 1907

The stand which Dr. Magnes has taken against the Hebrew Union College, of which he is a graduate, is one which should meet with the approval not only of Zionists, but also of all who are in sympathy with reform Judaism. There is nothing inherent in the reform idea which is opposed to Zionist ideals unless the former be twisted out of all shape and made to represent only a temporary phase of Jewish life. It is surprising that reform rabbis have not opposed, before this, the idea that reform Judaism is in principle antagonistic to Zionism. There is no "reform" synod to hamper the freedom of the reform pulpit.

The elections in Russia have resulted in the election of three Jews and five Marrano-Jews. The three Jewish deputies appear to be of slight value, and it is now rumored that the Marrano-Jews will espouse the Jewish cause in the Duma. It is a sad reflection on Jewish statemanship that partisan zeal has brought about a condition of affairs in which the Jewish interest is represented by fewer men than in the last Duma. With more experience and with a better understanding of the situation, there was no good reason for the lack of direction. But with the Bund active as socialists, and with the Jewish National party in the field to confuse issues and the Zionists beset on all sides by conflicting opinion, it is a wonder, indeed, that any Jewish candidates were elected. It remains to be seen whether the Jews in the attitude of petitioners will receive as much consideration as they would have received with a few dozen Jewish deputies in Parliament.

WE' wonder how long the American Israelite will keep up its sneering attitude toward the Zionist movement. It is difficult to understand what good it can see in the adoption of such a narrow-minded course of action. There is not another Jewish paper in this country, no matter how much it may be opposed to Zionism, that would consider it dignified or proper to sneer at every move the Zionists may make in this country. On the contrary, such opponents as Dr. Hirsch and Dr. J. Leonard Levy and Dr. Voorsanger are always eager to declare that Zionism has been a valuable factor in the revival of interest in Jewish thuoght and ideals. The American Israelite, untrue to the traditions of liberality and fair play of the founder of the journal, does not hesitate even to color its foreign news in order to give its readers the impression that Zionism is losing ground.

THE JEWISH FRATERNAL ORGANIZATIONS.

For some time the American Zionist Organization has been contemplating a move in the direction of securing the co-operation of the Jewish fraternal orders. These orders were organized to help the Jewish poor, to give financial and moral aid to its members in their time of need, and also to ameliorate, if possible, the condition of the Jewish people, the source of their membership. With such objects, it is clearly their duty also to assist Zionists in the solution of the broader questions of Jewish life. They will not be asked to give up their own work, but to extend it.

The Jewursh T’oice ıs opposed to the idea. “Let the Jewish orders alone,” ıt says, with some vehemence Zionism will hinder “ the general scheme” of the orders, and the Foice calls upon “every fair-minded worker in these circles to repel these attempts.” This Voice is an echo of the fast-waning provincialism in American Jewish thought. “Do not disturb us; let us keep to our old narrow paths,” says this provincialism; “let us stick to our limited, petty work, for any large endeavor will kill us.” But there have been indications that the leaders of the fraternal orders see