The Maccabaean · Vol. XII, No. 4 · April 1907
156printed page
scan 38 of 52
Facsimile · scan 38 of 52
Scan of p. 156
Text · transcribed from the scan

Antecedents, heredity, early environment, sometimes count more in a man's character than the mechanical training he receives in later life. And for Judaism this means that the determining force, in the long run, is apt to be the undercurrent of sentiment and traditon which is now showing itself, rather than the boastful formulas that have seemed to triumph for a time.

The third factor to which I referred as making in roads into the old Reform, is the development of Zionism. Whether the two movements are reconcilable or not, or whether they need to be reconciled at all I shall not argue here. Suffice it to say that Zionism links itself more naturally and easily to traditional Judaism than to any orthodoxical Reform, or crystallized factional creed. And the degree to which both teachers and students of the Reform have been attracted to Zionist ideals has become notable.

The early Zionists who find little or no encouragement at the hands of religious teachers thought it advisable to separate Jewish state questions from religious questions. For years this separation was maintained so that the opponents of the movement spoke of it from a political point of view as “the Zionist peril.” That was the title of the clearest presentation of the case against Zionism in the English language. Its author, Mr. Lucien Wolf, has since become a territorialist, a “half-Zionist.” Of late years, however, both within the Zionist camp and without, attempts have been made to remove the distinction between the religious and the political in Zionism,* and ıt is on the religious side that the controversy in which the Hebrew Union College finds itself involved has been raging. The “peril” question has been settled. and now it's one of “heresy.” It is fortunate for Zionism and unfortunate for its rabid opponents that we are living in the twentieth century and therefore do not fear inquisitions, and that we are Jews, and therefore put no faith in heresy trials. The truth has a better chance of winning out, N. T. 1.

N. T. I.

*Thus Professor Margolis insists on basing the Jewish state idea on the traditional religious view of "one God, one people"—monotheism and monoethnism.

THE CRYPTO ZIONIST

From time immemorial the wise men have gone to the East. Rabbi Voorsanger has gone East in search of knowledge. He is even going on a mission which will carry him to Palestine. Halfway, or two-thirds over, he has stopped at Paris and meeting Dr. Nordau has discovered from him something new in Zionism. In his own words, “I have discovered in Nordau what I can not discover in many American Zionists, a blending of political and philosophical Zionism.” We are inclined to draw a bead on that sentence and riddle it through and through. How can there, for instance, be a political Zionism that is without its philosophy? What is statecraft, in the main, if not an applied philosophy? And so on, and so on. We are, however, not over anxious to rise in defence of American Zionism which can take good care of itself, but frankly, Nordau has not helped Voorsanger “to rediscover America.” If rediscovery there be, it is of the California Rabbi’s own volition and Nordau was only the opportunity. Not one of us is “the mere advocate of escape from political oppression.” All of us hope for a Jewish state because we have discovered the great latent strength of our own people and believe that strength may come to its full fruition within the old geographical limitations. Rob us of that and we are mere “men of the earth”—Territorialists.

Just what Zion spells to us makes the sum of our philosophy. Herzl started out, even as some of our earliest publicists did with an "over there" state, and improved on them in that he included Zion in his optional "over there." But the people who responded to his state idea immediately wrote across it "Zion"—and so the state idea and futurity again linked itself together on Zion. Many of Voorsanger's Rabbinical colleagues read Zion out of the Jewish heart by aid of a formal resolution, but the executive power was lacking, so that Zion is still the "sesame" to Jewish idealism. The fact outweighs a ton of argument.

J. DE H.