The Zionist Observer
THE ZIONIST HERESY
What is wrong with the Hebrew Union College? Rumors of sensational denunciations, public statements, confused newspaper accounts, ofhicial denials and wholesale resignations have been shocking, inspiring, amusing. interesting, repelling and confounding all those who try to follow current events in the Jewish religious world for some time. Of course, in such yamim raim le-yisrael it is possible that there may be mixed in a strong personal element, a machloketh shello leshem shamaiım, a quarrel not in in the name of heaven, but that is none of our business here. What is strictly our affair, is that part of the contest which is more than personal, which represents a real conflictt of movements: Schechter zs. Kohler; Schloessinger vs. Philipson; Margolis vs. Enelow, Rubinstein and the rest, to say nothing of the acts and experiences of four members of the college faculty, nat mentioned here, who have at different times been declared “martyrs to the cause of Zionism.”
What does it all mean?
To us it clearly indicates a coming readjustment in the Reform camp, which from the nature of the case is inevitable. A reform can hold its own as long as it is not dogmatic, but once it is crystallized, it has all the objectionable phases of orthodoxy with none of its advantages. While American Reform was destructive, ıt was untroubled by any doubts, but now that, as is generally conceded, it has gone too far, its difficulties appear. In a conversation with a non-Zionistic rabbi, a son of one of the leading men of Reform Judaism, we were able to agree that the work before the present generation of rabbis is far different from the destructive work of the last generation, and it is far more difficult. It is precisely because the older generation of Reform cannot be reformed without a
struggle. And it is because we Jews have no heresy trials that our self-ordained popes and bishops must content themselves with hurling anathema at the effects of a man's religious views, rather than at the views themselves; at Zionism, rather than his denial of their abstract gods. Thus do rabbis exercise their cherem instinct even after the cherem has passed away, just as a ram butts to no avail after its horns are broken off.
To see clearly what the outcome of the struggle will be does not require the power of prophecy. It is enough to consider the causes that have led to the recent reaction and ask, "Will they grow in their imprtance or will they be cut off?"
These causes are the demands of progress, the influx of Russo-Polish Judaism into America and the development of Zionism.
Dr. Schloessinger has shown, in his recent discussion of "Reform Judaism and Zionism," that the same progress which at one period left the rabbis no choice and rendered the Reform movement necessary for many, has brought us to a point where something new is again required, and that is, according to his view, Zionism. Even those who have not joined the Zionist movement are apt to agree that the problems of Judaism have not been settled for all time, and many feel that a restatement of principles is necessary.
A more remarkable cause for the reaction is the fact that Jewish life in America is now fed and nourished by other than Reform sources. Many of the students and instructors come from intensely religious surroundings, else they would not have studied for the ministry at all. When they mature, and develop views different from those for which the college stands, its heads are puzzled and even angered. It is like the story of the old hen that hatched duck eggs, and when the little ducklings came out and swam away. she gazed out after them in helpless astonishment.