The Maccabaean · Vol. XII, No. 4 · April 1907
140printed page
scan 22 of 52
140
THE MACCABAEAN.

Russian Leaders on Zionism

Zionism will not Interfere with Emancipation in Russia

WHAT do they think of Zionism? is the decisive query of all anti-Zionists. If the Jewish people, by dint of great effort and many contortions, will take up with Jewish nationalism, what will the world, the benefactors of us poor emancipated Jews, have to say? Time and again they have been answered: The world has no objections to your national emancipation. It is you who must act for your best interests; the world appreciates the independent man. Do you want to be respected? Do not ask what you are to do in order to be respected by the man whose respect you expect to win. If you want to be free, do not ask your driver what you ought to do in order to be free. Respect yourself, free yourself, and then see what will happen!

The Bundists and other anti-Jews have insisted that if the Jews raise to question of Zionism before Russia is freed, then Jewish emancipation will be endangered. "Lie low, say nothing, and in the melree, you too will be liberated, and no embarrassing question will be asked. Once you mention the word Zionism, good-bye to your golden hopes of the future."

Again the goyim have taught Jews a lesson. Several prominent Russian leaders have been asked, what do you think of Zionism? Will Zionism endanger the future emancipation of the Jews? And this is what they have answered:

N. P. Anensky, the well-known writer, and one of the founders of the "National Socialist Party," said:

"There can be no doubt that the Jews should get equal rights with the Russians. That question and the question concerning our attitude towards Zionism are two different things. Whether there will be Deputies in the Duma that will openly declare themselves Zionists, or whether there will be no such Deputies, that will not in the least alter our attitude and will not hinder us from defending the cause of equal rights for the Jews. As for me,

personally, I wish the Jews to remain in Russia. And if Russia were to encourage a widespread Jewish emigration, I should consider its work neither proper nor practical. I recognize, however, that after all that has happened, the Jews have the moral right to seek a way out of their painful condition, and as we Russians have not proved by our deeds that we are able to guarantee to the Jews a life that would satisfy them, we have no moral right to keep them away from Zionism. Our opposition to Zionism should be expressed only in the following way: We must do everything in our power to make the Jews feel that ‘'ey are not strangers among us. We must give them equal rights without any exceptions whatever and treat them so that they should have no desire to look elsewhere for the solution of the Jewish auestion.

"If the Zionist tendency among the Jews would really cause us to change our attitude concerning equal rights for the Jews, it would merely show that the sense of real equality is not alive within our breasts. No Zionism does not interfere with our struggle for equal rights for the Jews."

Professor P. N. Miliukov, the well-known economist and leader of the Constitutional Democratic Party, said:

“It is ridiculous to say that if there will be Zionists in the Duma, the Jews will not get equal sıghts. I have always regarded Zionism as a dream which cannot be realized. But it has not only made Jewish life more beautiful in a certain sense, it has also proved very useful in that it has strengthened the courage of the Jewish people, it has elevated the Jews in their own eyes and has thus prepared them for the struggle for a better future. If the Zionists in the Duma will show that they go hand in hand with the progressive element in Russia and will participate in the struggle for freedonı, Zionism will in no way change our attitude toward equal rights for all. It makes no difference to us whether the Jewish representatives will be Zionists or not. It is un-