The Maccabaean · Vol. XII, No. 3 · March 1907
101printed page
scan 25 of 52

and modes of speech, with various customs and habits, to re-establish themselves on a national territory, where they shall be reunited and free to develop a composite, the result of environment, which shall be the character of Jewish citizenship; and, in addition, while this territory is being acquired, so to work on the various groups that their elements shall at once be inspired to devote themselves to the actual revival of national consciousness, the refinement of the national language, the cherishing of national ideals and tradition, in order to forestall the day when the territory shall be acquired; and before it is legally acquired to be continuously spurred on to hasten the return, to be precipitated into the land, there to be in a position to act as one people, as the nucleus of the future free and independent nation.

With such Zionism is American or English or French patriotism incompatible?

Zionists have eagerly, and too hastily, replied that it is not. Probably, when that position was first taken, it was because they were not so sure of their ground, especially- in America. They were not so sure that Palestine was a reality to them, that Zionism was an actuality in their own lives. The more definite Zionism becomes. the closer its appeal, the better understood its aims, the more real it becomes to the Jew, the more incongruous it becomes in the light of genuine American patrotism. The nearer Palestine is brought, the more devoted the American Zionist must become not to the Stars and Stripes, American literature, life, and art, its economic welfares, but to the blue and white flag, and that land. which rises out of the dim past and whose outlines become ever more and more distinct.

I, personally, cannot see how a man vitally interested in Palestinian conditions, in the revival of a national language and literature, in devoting himself to the education of himself and his children in Jewish knowledge, in the stimulation of his feelings as a Jew, and with making the word Jew a strong, impelling force in his complete life, not as a study but as a sys-

tem of life, can, at the same time, assert that the future of the American nation, its civilization, its morality, its prophets, are vital to his existence or that they are not, in his eyes, like the interest he has in so-called foreign civilizations. Undoubtedly he is not actually an American. He has cast his fate with another race, to be settled on another soil, to be educated by another tradition, etc. He is caught up by a different current.

I feel that the Zionist Jew must consider his position as if he were a shipwrecked traveler who has been rescued and well treated by his rescuers. He has lived years and years in their midst, has accustomed himself to their life, is naturally interested in their welfare, and will do anything to indicate that he is anxious to pay his debt to them. But when the call comes from his own people, and their land requires his interest, he is bound, the more insistent the call becomes, to say: I have, until now, repaid you all it was in my power to give you. Now, my own compatriots call me, and, though I may sojourn in your midst for one, two generations, I must respond to the call; I must go back to those, he concludes, with whom I am linked by ties older than the ties I have formed here.

In other words, he is bound to declare himself eventually either an American or a Zionist; there can be no unity there. Nature abominates double allegiances; and a divided individual, like a divided nation, cannot stand.

We are not dealing, now, with logical syllogisms. Logically, it is possible to be interested, say, in an American murder trial, and Conder's description of Palestine. It is possible to be a good Democrat, and at the same time hold fast to the cultur form of Zionism. But whatever logic may claim for the individual, life does not adjust itself to intellectual demands; the one interest is bound to exclude the other. Zionism is buond gradually to expatriate the American Jews.

Naturally, the sympathies of American Zionists will always be with the American people. Our childhood has been fed by the