“Stronger Than Love”
Carmen Sylva on the Jews and Judaism
“In our house ‘Nathan the Wise’ is a daily visitor, for we have all faiths represented in our own family: Catholic, Protestant, and Orthodox; we even have a Jew in our house as secretary! And it happens to be an Israelite who is my chief supporter in all deeds of charity . . . . .”
Do you want to know who has written these lines, who sets before us this Nathan-the-Wise Philosophy? It is the Queen of Roumania, known as "Carmen Sylva." "The Jews are the only people who have experienced no decay, they have remained firm and strong, united, helpful to each other, healthy, prolific and mighty. And for all this they are indebted to one man, the greatest ruler the world has ever seen, the king of kings, the wisest physician, the greatest psychologist and physiologist that has even lived Moses! Who could live on a throne without bowing down before Moses in worship?"
Now isn’t not this fine testimony, offered by a royal hand? The Jews, a healthy, well-preserved, unified, a mighty people! Such people must be for all countries of the world a true blessing; a delicium human generis! Carmen Sylva does not have to go very far out of her way to sec, she has simply to look about in her own land, in the “Bojaren-land,” Roumania, there, there are plenty of Jewish people to furnish the eorroboration of her theory. For exampie, she may prove to herself at any instant how mighty this people is. She can prove to herself what this people, in spite of its intellectual strength, in spite of its endurance, may accomplish against a stultified, hostile, brutal mtilieu. King Carol and Queen Elizabeth have already had more than twenty-five years’ opportunity to think of the life of the Roumanian Jews, the true, real, naked life of the Jewish people. Here it is not a Jacob Bernays, a learned man, resigned, a Jew simply out of reverence for the past. Here it is not Nathan-
types that appear before their eyes, not abstractions, not ideals, but simple men; living Jews. And how has the exalted opinion of Carmen Sylva about the Jews translated itself into practice? I know of no better contrast of the "truth" and the "poetry" in this case than a little poem that has in turn been dedicated to the queen-poetess.
“Trembling old men are stamm’ring.
Scarce can their anguish tell—Whisp’ring the ancient Hebrew,
The “Hear, O Israel!” Some little Jew is falling, Clubbed in his narrow pale—The queen is sweetly singing Songs of the nightingale.
Watchmen are growing fretful. Why should they longer wait? Hurry the homeless wanderers Through the next dark suffering-gate.
What though anchors are lifted,
What though poor exiles flee— Carmen Sylva is warbling An Ode to Humanity!”
Oscar Wilde once said that a poet does not write simply when and because he feels, but rather when and because he wills to write. It may be a wretched paradox, but in the case of Carmen Sylva it fits well. She is not a poetess by the grace of God, whose creations are visions that well up out of subeonsciousness, and lose themselves in the infinite. She is a ruler by the grace of God, who has poetie aspirations and who knows how to clothe her highly rationalistic view of life ın a more or less poetic form. A real poet is not responsible for his verses. Why does Carmen Sylva preach humanity, when she does not make the slightest attempt to prevent the undeserved misery. of the hundreds of thousands of Jews who dwell in her land?
Is it not a mockery when Carmen Sylva, now. a few weeks after a horrible massacre of Jews in Roumania, where a few loose, raw, rough young men, the "golden youth" of the country, in barbaric fashion fell upon the Jews, and for this were praised by the whole land. yes, publicly by