The Maccabaean · Vol. XII, No. 2 · February 1907
58printed page
scan 24 of 52

that must be exceedingly startling to the Russian rulers of to-day. They must appear as fanciful as anything ever proposed by the most idealistic Zionist. From an American point of view, some of these principles are such commonplaces of government as to seem strange when explicitly stated. Local self-government, freedom of religious practice, right to establish schools of any sort, are such principles as are automatically accepted. On the other hand, some of the demands of the new Jewish party seem, perhaps, even more bizarre to the American intelligence than they do to the Russian. The demand for national autonomy, not only for national groups, that constitute majorities in certain territorial districts, but also for national minorities, is one that would make an American statesman gasp. State and City autonomy within their respective provinces is, indeed, at the root of the American political system. But this autonomy is merely one distributed among territorial divisions that are fundamentally alike in racial characteristics. The idea of racial autonomy within the United States is abhorrent to the American political conscience. On the contrary, racial amalgamation is a kind of article of faith of the

American statesman. But here we have a political party in Russia, in the greatest despotism of the world, coolly proposing national autonomy for each nationality in a majority in the district in which it resides, and a sort of modified autonomy, or proportional representation, for each nationality having a majority equal to a certain percentage of the whole population of the district! The adoption of this plan would be to establish a federal system very far different from that of the United States. It would be, to a large extent, a confession of sin on the part of the Russian monarchy for its historic predaceousness. It would be an attempt to restore national life in the victims of her conquests whom until now she has held paralyzed, as insects are kept by wasps—not dead, but with sufficient life in them to preserve them from dissolution. Whether this is a practical solution of Russia ’s great problem, or of the Jewish problem, seems doubtful. The examples of Austria-Hungary, Norway and Sweden, and other countries seem to be against it. But to the Jews, amelioration of their actual condition must come from almost any plan aiming at liberty and equality of rights.