hour, although undoubtedly in many cases their private sentiments were directly antagonistic to those of nationalism.
This inner conflict manifested itself at every conference of the Jewish group of delegates, but every effort was made to keep it hidden in order to present a united front to the enemy. It was impossible, however, to keep up the appearance of harmony indefinitely, and now Mr. Winawer has finally concluded the time to be opportune for coming out in opposition to the Zionist wing of the Jewish group. His signing of the Viborg manifesto has made him ineligible for election to the next Duma. Having no fear as to the effect his step may have upon his candidacy, about which he was solicitous during the first elections, he feels himself free, apparently, to avow his real opinions. That his present opinions are not due to any recent action of the Zionists is clear from the fact that there is scarcely any difference of any consequence between the principles adopted by the Wilna conference, which inaugurated the “League for the Promotion of Equal Rights for the Jews,” and the program of the last Zionist convention at Helsingfors. Mr. Winawer could accept the latter as well as the former, if he had a strong enough incentive to do so.
The Zionists are accused by their former associates of narrowness and impracticality. A circumstance of the present campaign shows how little foundation there is to the charge. One of the candidates supported by the Zionists of Wi!na is a man named Gruzenberg, who has been a vehement opponent of Zionism. He has, however, eccepted the nationalistic principles of the He:singfors conference. Mr. Winawer has suddenly begun to talk about his ardent affeetion for his dear fatherland, Russia. But, of course, he knows, or ought to know, well enough, that political and eivil rights are never granted to a disfranchised people in return fer love, and Russia is certainly not the country in which such an ethical example will be offered to the world. Political rights must be wrung from tyrants by force or they must be obtained by inexor-
able bargaining. The Jews in Russia will get their rights not by professing love for the fatherland, but by convincing the ruling powers that for their own peace and welfare no other course is open to them than to grant the rights that are demanded. If political and civil rights are due to those who have rendered service to the fatherland, Russia has long owed those rights to the Jews. The debt has matured and the time to pay is at hand. The Jews of Russia bear more than their share of the burden of taxation, and there are at present in active service in the Russian army over sixty thousand Jewish soldiers.. The begging tone Mr. Winawer has seen fit to adopt is scarcely in keeping with his character as elear-haesden statesman.
Dozens of parties have sprung up and disappeared in Russia and the probabilities are that this latest party wi.l share the fate of its predecessors. The Jews are too keen not to see the danger of such unmeaning dissensions in their ranks. Their political sense is too well developed to allow them to fritter away their strength in that fashion, and undoubtedly before election-time they will have got together and removed all such diflierences, which spring up in a moment in the excited brains of a faw hot-heads. The strength of the enemy is too well known to be trifled with. Already the chances of electing a Jewish deputy from Wilna are smaller than they were at the previous election. It will require the united effort of all the Jews there te send a man to the Duma who will represent Jewish interest. The same is true in other places. Union is possible only on one basis—the basis of a Jewish nationalistic program. Give up that, and you give up the only hope of harmonious action; splits and dissensions begin without end. Factional disputes are not inaugurated for the purpose of promoting unity, but to create division.
The program of general and special principles enunciated and signed by Messrs. Winawer, Sliosberg, Kulisher, Ostrogorsky, Sheftel, Posner, Goldstein, Sternberg, D. Levin, Sev, Syrkin, Tribus, Hessen, Cornfeld, and Stilman, embodies ideas
