The Maccabaean · Vol. XII, No. 2 · February 1907
44printed page
scan 10 of 52
Facsimile · scan 10 of 52
Scan of p. 44
Text · transcribed from the scan

sold their birthright for the fleshpots of Egypt, the Midrash tells us, perished in the Egyptian darkness.. With the bulk of the people Moses prevailed. He won them for ‚the idea of Jewish liberty, not for liberty in. ‚the abstract. He taught them the lesson that if they were to become free they must negotiate with Pharaoh, but leave Egypt with a high hand. They must emancipate themselves and thus become a nation. Pharaoh could, after all, grant equal rights to individuals, but not to the nation within the nation. As individuals they might prosper to a certain extent; with freedom of movement and with the removal of all legislative restrietions, they might enrich themselves even as they would contribute to the prosperity of Egypt; they might even have another Jew as a member of the Pharaonic cabinet; they would share in the wisdom of Egypt and successfully compete with the magicians—but the Jewish question in Egypt would not be solved.

There might go out the watchword, Disperse the Jews, remove them from the congested distriets—but the instincet of the Jew, which a Moses understood, was for concentration. If concentrate they must, let them concentrate on their own soil. In Egypt, at the very best, they can only be Egyptians of a second order. With characteristic nervousness they will proclaim their Egyptianism from the housetops, display the flag in their religious school houses and the Egyptian colors in their houses of worship, collect data concerning “their” soldiers who served in some Ethiopian war and publish in some pretentious volumes the meagre facts of Egyptian Jewish history. Aye, when one day they will celebrate some anniversary of the landing of Jewish settlers in the land of Goshen, Egyptians in high political and educational positions will give their testimony to Jewish loyalty and civie rectitude, here and there coupled with references to “something of separateness” ın their social life among the Egyptians, or with the bidding to place above their separate interests and their separate inheritance, “the great common heritage of the nation and the nation’s

Maith.” The outsider will not fail to tell them that they are a race with “race traditions,” a people “distinct, individual, unmistakable,” a “cohesive nationality, which no disaster has destroyed, no misfortune weakened, no lapse of time impaired.”

A Moses understood the anomalous character of Israel in Egypt. By the side of the other nationalities, more or less rapidly losing themse:ves in the nation at large, a concentrated Jewry would be a problem to Egypt, and a dispersed Jewry a problem to Israel. For, in the latter case, ultimate absorption stared them in the face, which to resist, some said, was folly, if not a crime against nature. For nature is rarely catastrophic, spending her forces in a day; patiently she commits her purpose to the evolution of years. She destroys a minority wedged in the nation’s organism by slow stages, by disintegrating those on top who are ready for submersion, and by converting those below, beginning with the outiandish immigrant, into the next higher stratum until the top is reached where are found the numerically fewest and the culturally fittest. The process of absorption had begun in the days of Moses; it remained, however, latent in the masses, graded and slow assimilation being the anresthetic benignly supplied by nature, while the e.ders of Israel were administering to moribund Jewry & theological anaesthetic in the convenient formula of “squaring practice with theory.”

A Moses is not a mere diplomat whose aim is to solve the Jewish question. Nor is he moved solely by the Jewish misère, the groaning of the children of Israel whom the Egyptians kept in bondage. He is the prophet sent by the Lord to redeem from Egypt “the nation and its God.” For in Egypt not only Israel, we are told in the Midrash, was held in bondage, but also the Shekinah. The sh’bud ha-Shekinah, the spiritual bondage of Israel, the sterility of the native Jewish genius and the dissipation of Jewish energy, are the great concern of Moses. There were Jews in Egypt who maintained that the Jewish genius was original but in one direction, the so-called religious. And religion meant with them a