plea therefore for the present manhood, for character, and creative activity.
WETTEN MAR VALLE TAV DOKU VE AL, Ye In the final chapters of this book, Prof. Genung treats, first, of the apocryphal books of wisdom; these he considers marked no advance in ideals, but were intermediaries of the reciprocal dissemination of Greek and Jewish culture; and secondly, the Christian literature of wisdom represented inthe New Testament. Prof. Genung compares the Old Testament wisdom writinvs to the chapter in Carlyle’s Sartor Resartus entitled the “Everlasting Nay”; the apocryphal books to the “Centre of Indifference”: and those in the New Testament to the “Everlasting Yea.” In other words, he believes that the negative work accomplished in Job and Koheleth finds fruit in the positive philosophy of Jesus. This philosophy may be briefly summarized as “creative lore.” The problem of reward for good and evil is annihilated by an appeal to originality, to the pulsations of the free, enlightened spirit. He who has love is a lord, eonsciously direeting his universe, since he dares give good on:!y, never receive evil; this is the “wisdom of God.” For does God seek reward for his love? No more should we. Each should have in himself a fund for eternal life, to expend here on earth in works of radiant love. The Epistle of James, it should be noted, is eloser in tone to the Old Testament wisdom. Moulton quotes many passages that resemble similar passages in Ecclesisaticus; like that book it is in many respects simply a manual of conduct.
What shall be said of allthis? Tt ıs evident at a first glance that Prof. Genung has accepted boldly the principle laid down in his preface, and told us what, in his opinion, the Hebrew literature of Wisdom means, not what it meant. Like every man with a theory, he has had often to warp the facts to suit his theory. His constant tendency everywhere, it is apparent, is to assign greater coherency to the Biblical books than, after the mutation of ages, they actually possess. Thus it is in a measure absurd to deduce a definite philssophical creed from the diseconneeted observations of the Pro-
verbs; the prudential attitude of mind that Prof. Genung finds in them is assuredly not absent, but such sentiments as “love covereth all sins” are also present; and many maxims of Jesus, as Dr. Abbott for example points out, are taken almost literally from Proverbs. In this interpretation of Job, Prof. Genung is espeeially interesting and has least need to “read into” the facts; but Koheleth, on the contrary, is certainly twisted beyond recognition in his hands. Ile has picked out a number of isolated sentencees and made them the groundwork of his interpretation. Attractive the interpretation is, no doubt; but to discover Carlyle’s Gospel of Work in Koheleth is to apply the latter’s weary sigh of “nothing new under the sun” a bit too literally. Koheleth, as is well known, has been subjected to almost as many diverse interpretations as Shakspere’s sonnets; it has been called an address by Jesus to the saints and a chroniele of the kings of the house of Judah from Solomon to Zedekiah; an anticipation of the Harveian theory of the cireulation of the blood and a treatise on the Summum Bonum. It is hardly likelv that we shall ever know what it really means. We must regard the Koheleth as tampererd wıth—tampered with, moreover, by (deeds both of commission and omission. For we cannot but suppose that the ecelesiastical authorities, shocked by the pessimistie tones of the book, deleted portions of the argument and interspersed pious antidotes. Thus in two direcetions has Koheleth become difieult to understand: there is both more and less than what the author wrote. But undoubtedly the creed ot the book is destructive in character: Koheleth is an early Omar Khayyam, a primitive Faust in his early stages of despair. It is likely that even originally the book was merely a “journal of fragments;;” Dr. Abbott compares it in this respeet to the Journal of Amiel. So Moulton also very wisely insists that if the literary form of Koheleth be examined, “the attempt to trace a continous argument from beginning to end must be dismissed.” The one thing that we can be sure of in Koheleth is that