lem of the reward for righteousness. What yıthron, what surplusage, what profit remains to us of all our labor that we labor under the sun? Every book in this wisdom literature, according to Prof. Genung, gives its own answer to this question. In Proverbs, the reward for piety is success and prosperity in this world. Fear God and keep his commandments, says Proverbs, and God will reward you with wealth and wisdom and power and all things good. The righteous shall be recompensed and the sinner go to destruction, all here on earth. The constant note of Proverbs is a tranquil asgurance of this truth. But now comcs a new problem. The reward of piety, say the sages, is prosperity; then comes the perplexing question: Is righteousness to be made merely dependent on material reward? Job, is what Prof. Genung calls the “attack by centre” on the apparent motives for piety as laid down in Proverbs. The problem ıs this: Job has been righteous in prosperity; if prosperity is suddenly taken away and misfortune and pain substituted, will Job, this average wise man, maintain his righteousness? In order to present the drama in Job’s soul more vividly, the author of this remarkable book ar- rays against Job in his misery, visible exponents of the older philosophy of reward. Stubbornly they cling to their dogma: if Job has been visited with evil, it must be because he has deserved it; never yet have they seen the righteous other than prosperous and happy. “Job!” they say, “search thy soul; thou has surely sinned.” With conscious pride they parade their neat maxinıs; often of old has Job, himself, perpetrated similar “mashals” of complacent rectitude. But how does Job now answer them? With bitter reviling, with unwavering maintenance of his own righteousness, with accusation of a God who must be unjust, if indeed Job has done no wrong; of that he remains firmly convinced. The fauit lies elsewhere, not in him. Nor can the substance of his he intends always to punish only the guilty. arguırent be denied; so the wrath of Elihu is kindled against Job’s friends, as well as against him, “because they had found no
answer and yet had condemned Job." And what is the answer? God speaks from the whirlwind, and he convinces Job of the futility to judge Him by his poor human faculties; but Job himself is justified. By true manliness and self-centred righteousness he had maintained his integrity; unlike his time-serving friends, who feared to offend God by frank and open speech. Truth and integrity.—these are wisdom and piety,—though the heavens fall and all men contend against you.
see = Dei ' Ense The next step in the wisdom literature Prof. Genung' finds in Koheleth, which he calls the “attack by flank.” In Job the question has been: Is it always for reward that a man is righteous? In Koheleth is posited a new, more ironical question: What is this’reward? What is it? The presentation is again: dramatic; the discourse is put into the mouth of the most wise and prosperous of men, Solomon. Here truly was a man with all things that this life can give—wealth, wisdom, power, material goods, mental endowments. But the end is vanity; allisa breath. Step by step Koheletıı tests everything, and all is vanity. The one hope, moreover, that he might have had, the hope of a future life wherein all would be righted, he consciously rejects, according to Prof. Genung, who regards Koheleth as a definite protest against the Greek notions of immortality introduced at this time, es- peeially -in the apoeryphal “Wisdom of Solomon.” But one consolation he finds, and Prof. Genung considers this consolation to be the central thought of the book. The profit for a man’s labor that he labors under the sun is—the labor. The reward of life is life itself; life is an ultimate fact with no world beyond the grave as a necessary supplement. For there must be no question of reward, either now or hereafter; no hard-and-fast bargainıngs in righteousness. On one other verse Prof.Genung lays emphasis: Everything hath He made beautiful in its time; also hath He put eternity in their heart.” ‘In other words, this life itself is eternal; our immortality is in us now. As a whole, Koheleth is a