The Maccabaean · Vol. XII, No. 1 · January 1907
27printed page
scan 31 of 50
Facsimile · scan 31 of 50
Scan of p. 27
Text · transcribed from the scan

thousands of others who could not gain admission. It seemed as if the whole East Side had wended its way to Durland's to hear Dr. Lewin. The meting was presided over by Mr. Schiff; besides Dr. Lewin, Dr. Magnes, Mr. Schiff and Mr. Cyrus L. Sulzberger also delivered addresses. Naturally the words of Dr. Lewin, who spoke on "The Condition of the Jews in Russia," met with the greatest amount of interest. At the conclusion of his address the whole audience rose, lustily cheered and waved Zionist banners with a fervor and persistency that made the hall look like a huge sea of Zionist banners vigorously set afloat by a whirlwind of contagious enthusiasm which pervaded every nook and cranny of the hall.

On Thursday, Dec. 20, Dr. Lewin spoke at Cooper Union ou “The Necessity of Zionism,” wherein he presented his brief in behalf of Zionism. It was an inspiring address, it touched the brains and hearts of those present. The Jews, Dr. Lewin said, had become near-sighted through their dwelling behind closed doors; there are very few Jews who can see very far with a clear, natural vision, as is evidenced by the fact that to the average Jew. the thought of the future of his people has no place in his mind.

Dr. Lewin received a hearty welcome in the other cities he visited. In Chicago Dr. Emil G. Hirsch and Adolphe Krause were in charge of the mass meeting which Dr. Lewin addressed. In Cincinnati, the stronghold of Reform Judaism, Dr. Lewin made an excellent impression. Our Cincinnati correspondent, who viewed things from behind the scenes, writes us as follows:

DR. LEWIN IN CINCINNATI.

Dr. Lewin was in Cincinnati on the 12th and 13th of December. The committee that arranged for his stay in the city consisted of two sections: the first, of Zionists who arranged a Yiddish mass meeting downtown, and the second, mostly of communal workers, not identified with the Zionist movement, who arranged a German meeting in Avondale. These were, without ex-

ception, the largest meetings ever addressed in Cincinnati by a Zionistic speaker. Prominent in both audiences were members of the Hebrew Union College, representetives of the anti-Zionistie press, and rabbis representing various shades of non-Zionist opinion. For many'of his hearers Dr. Lewin’s lectures were the first words on Zionism listened to directly from a Zionistic source. The immediate resuit—it is too early to speak of ultimate effects— was a revelation to many, or to put it in a prosier form, a rough shock to the self-satisfaction of some men who had absorbed all their opinions on Jews and Judaism in cold chunks from a time-serving press, a prejudiced rabbinate and a dogma-ridden institution.

Although Dr. Lewin stirred up a great deal of enthusiasm at these meetings—genuine enough downtown and more or less ephemeral on the hill, for we are determined not to deceive ourseives—the chief, or at least the most definite, result of his visit will be attributable not to his publie addresses but to his informal talks. I am told that he spoke for three-quarters of an hour in pure Hebrew at the Hebrew Union College and that a lively discussion between him and President Kohier ensued. It is hardly fair to judge the merits of the arguments of either by the effect on the students, for the magnetic personality of Dr. Jewin, as well as the natural claim on the interest of students enjoyed by a stranger, his superior grasp of his subject, his contagious good humor and enthusiasm and his absolute freedom from the mannerisms of the pulpit—all told immeasurably in favor of the ex-member of the Duma. Still I have been told by those who ought to know that never in the history of the institution have the future rabbis been carried away more completely by enthusiasm than they were after Dr. Lewin’s address. The same thing was true when he dined at the Phoenix Club. One very prominent member who has been sympathetic towards Zionism for some time and who is now a full-pledged Zionist, told me that he had never heard such clear-cut answers graced