The Contributors' Club
"Well I am a Zionist and I'm not."
'To the scoffers, Herzl was a dreamer andZionism a phantasy. "The Jewish nation?What Jewish nation? Palestine? Whocares for Palestine?" Thus they betrayedtheir utter materialism and lack of anyennobling emotions. "We are well off inEngland, in America; what do we needPalestine for?" said they. "For the persecuted Jews in Russia and the other eastern countries? Who told you that theJews are persecuted?" was the question before the pogroms and "The Jews are themselves to blame for the massacres" is theexplanation they now offer. Their formulaof existence is summed up in the words,"I live; why worry about the other man?He does not worry about me."
These are the people with whom Zionists have to contend and upon whom all arguments are wasted. If not for their influence over those who are always doubting and hesitating either through ignorance of conditions or lack of ability to draw their own conclusions, they could easily and profitably be ignored. But every now and then an ardent Zionist, trying to convince some sympathizer, is obliged to correct items of information which have been freely advanced from the great store existing in the imagination of one of these self-styled authorities.
And this is just the reason for the apparent lack of support which Zionism has found. At heart, every good Jew is a Zionist, but, just as one demagogue can corrupt the minds of an entire populace, so it is enough if these few scoffers, mentioned before, exist in a community to have, as a result of their plausible misrepresentations and illogical deductions from false premises, the majority in that community, which, as in every assemblage of men, usually consists of individuals who are ready to follow the first scoffer who chances along, hang back with un-
satisfactory answers when questioned concerning their beliefs. As has been said previously, the feeling which makes them incline to Zionism is really present and at heart the man is a good Zionist, but his Nationalism has been made sport of and he is afraid of compromising himself by making a definite statement, for fear of being laughed at again. The sting of ridicule and satire is sharp and very few men are brave enough not to fear it. So the bark of the cynic has its effect and the average Jew when asked will answer, “Well —I am a Zionist and I’m not—that is, I believe in Zionism to a certain extent, but —” and then he will give some ridiculous reason, varying with the individual and according to the ideas grafted upon him by some habitual cynic, for not being an open and through Zionist. The result is that, just as, in Spain, there existed a Marrano Judaism there now exists, but under different circumstances, a species of Marrano Zionism.
This state of affairs is universal among all peoples and will only cease when men are bold enough to be faithful to their convictions and not to be led astray by satirical sophistry.
Jos. I. DAVIDMAN.
A Dreamer
"A dreamer of dreams" his mother had playfully called him, when, at the first Seder he could remember, he sat, a tiny boy, and felt the true significance of the ceremonial. And it came back to him—the hurried flight, the march across the parted sea, the pursuit of the Egyptians. His soul answered to it all—he remembered. And so he remained, a dreamer of dreams.
As he grew to manhood the greatest of these dreams was Zion redeemed, the Jew, no longer an alien, an outcast, a something apart from other men, with-
