I know not whether Jacob Tugendhold in his swallow-tail coat is still among the living. At best he is a pensioned corpse, for the wicked are considered dead as soon as they have lost the power of exercising their wickedness, says the Talmud; the pious, however, it continues, are alive in death, and Meisels will survive for a long time in the memory of posterity.
The memorial services denied him at home were celebrated in the synagogue Rue Nazarene, Paris, by the colony of Polish emigrants, the overwhelming majority of them Christians. Those Christian pulpits
that have not yet adopted the fashion of lauding men of their own party only, have referred to his service in fitting terms, and the Jewish press of all shades of opinion have done honor to his memory.
What the outcome of the struggle of these step-brothers, Poland and Russia will be, who dares prophesy? But when, after the close of the struggle Freedom makes a list of her heroes and martyrs in Samartia's lands, Baer Meisels will not be forgotten. When the noblest names are mentioned, his name will be among them.
APPENDIX
In the sketch of Rabbi Meisel's life, it was mentioned that the Jewish prisoners in the citadel were asked to reply, in writing, to certain questions regarding the fraternization between Jewish and Christian citizens of the country, how it originated and how it developed. It happened accidently, or perhaps purposely, that on the same day these questions were presented to us, I was permitted to join Meisels in his cell. For personal reasons he had refused to commit himself upon the questions submitted to us, nevertheless he gladly gave me the benefit of his experience and advice. He must therefore be regarded as my collaborator in the preparation of the following paper, written in a prison cell and on paper of which the sheets had been carefully counted. Its fearless presentation of facts illustrates and does honor to the uprightness of the old man whose early years had been spent in an atmosphere of old-time Jewish shyness: while the same frankness comes naturally to a man thirty years his junior, and reared amid modern classic surroundings. Meisels fully realized our joint responsibility in his work . He knew that any dangers I incurred by a plainspoken presentation of the condition of the Jews and the attitude of the Government toward them, would fall no less lightly on him than on me, but he willingly shared the
risks as well as the work. Upright and prudent as he was by nature, his advice could only result in producing a careful yet frank, statement of facts.
Those interested in the status of the Jews in Poland and the fate of the Polish Jew elsewhere, may besides find this essay of historical interest, as a characterization of the times and the local conditions.
So far as I can remember the wording, the following are the points I was requested to discuss:
1. "When the Jews were being persecuted by the Christians, why did they notappeal to the Government, that is to say,—the Governor?
2. What benefit did the Jews hope to derive from their fraternity with the Christians?
3. How was this fraternization brought about?
Name the persons particularly active in this consummation.
"You are requested to make a full and frank statement concerning the above-mentioned circumstances."
It can easily be conceived that the damp-cell of the casemates of the Russian fortress was hardly the place in which to produce the frank and free expression of opinion required of me. Nevertheless there was more danger connected with the refus-
