Through the Magazines
In the Nineteenth Century and After, Sir Philip Magnus writes on the methods of teaching employed in early Jewish school teaching:
teaching. “The aim of education among the Jews was national rather than individual. They believed that in the success of their schools lay all hope of preserving and promoting the study of the Law, which was their inheritance, and of thus fulfilling the purpose of their existence. “Children are born,” says Erasmus, “for the State and for God,” a doctrine as old as Plato, but in no country were its consequences so unreservedly accepted as in Palestine. Nothing is more characteristic of the Jews than their devotion to study, but very little thought was given to what we are always being told should be the practical results of school training. . .
The secret of discipline was interest: the interest aroused in the study, and, above all, the interest of parents in what their children were learning. The sympathy of the parent with the efforts of the schoolmaster made his task a pleasure, and instruction easy. Learning by heart formed a large part of the teaching both in the elementary and higher schools. That was mainly oral. At the same time reading was generally taught, and the Hebrew language was systematically studied. Many mnemonic rules are given in the Talmud for assisting the memory, but constant repetition was considered the surest method, and in this respect the teaching was very similar to that of comparatively modern times. The Latin rule, Repetitio mater est studiorum, is otherwise figuratively expressed in the saying: ‘He who studies without repeating is like the man who sows and does not reap.’ And elsewhere: ‘He who repeats a matter a hundred times does not understand it as well as he who repeats it a hundred and one times.’ In an age when there were no publishers, and conce-quently no text-books, it was necessary that the pupil should first fix in his memory the subject of the lesson and then seek
to understand it. Hence we find the saying, 'First know the matter and then learn to explain it,' an analytical principle of teaching of wider application than it probably received in the Talmudic schools. 'Knowledge is gained,' says the Talmud, 'by help of the memory.' But from a comparatively early age the pupil was trained in methods of inquiry, and was encouraged to ask questions. The fault that prevailed for so many years in modern colleges, where the teacher talked and the student listened, was unknown in Talmudic seminaries. The instruction was much more lively. There was a constant and brisk interchange of thought between teacher and pupil. . . .
The school buildings were generally outside the town, away from the busy hum of men. During the lesson the children sat on the floor in a half-circle, and the teacher on a raised seat in the center. The schoolhouse and synagogue were often in the same building, and, even to the present day, the house of prayer is known in Germany as Schule and in Italy as Scuola. Indeed, in olden times the training of the home, of the school, and of the synagogue were one and the same. The distinction between religious and secular instruction was unknown. In the impressive words of a German writer: 'As the child went forth each morning from his father's house into the synagogue and thence into the seminary, he went from one house of God into another, and one Book and one Spirit accompanied him, whether at home, in school, or in the house of prayer.' . . .
The respect and esteem in which the Rabbi was held in Talmudic days is being gradually extended to the schoolmaster and to the professor of modern times. Slowly but certainly we are coming to regard the schools of the people as the nation's stronghold, and to see in their efficiency the country's real strength and civilizing power. This idea was ever present to the minds of the Jewish sages whose wisdom is recorded in the pages of the Talmud."