The Maccabaean · Vol. XI, No. 2 · August 1906
98printed page
scan 40 of 48
Facsimile · scan 40 of 48
Scan of p. 98
Text · transcribed from the scan

Zionist Programs

An Open Letter to all Zionist Societies

By Nathan T. Isaacs

When the Zionists of America decided unanimously to regard Zionism as a political movement, they no doubt knew exactly what they meant, but their form of expression, if I may be allowed the privilege of saying so, was unfortunate. We can not set aside certain acts to declare them political and others to call social, still others religious or moral or economic, without finding a great deal of overlapping at every turn. The truth is that all acts and activities have their social bearing, all acts have their religious or moral phase and all acts have their political and economic significance.

The political phase of Zionism is its most important aspect at the present time, but the movement has its religious, economic, social and cultural phases as well, and no good will result from shutting our eyes to these. Of course we can not expect a Congress, whose functions are primarily those of a bureau of foreign relations, to take charge of anything but the political direction of the movement. Still, unless development in other respects is proportionate, something will be found wrong somewhere when the attempt is made to put together the structure for which the boards are now being cut. Where, then, and by whom shall the non-political work of Zionism be carried on?

"How's Zionism in your city?" This question seemed to be the official greeting among the delegates at Tannersville. Shall I tell you the usual answers? "Well, things are pretty quiet just now; you see there is really nothing definite that we can do to keep our members interested." After conferring with delegates from nearly every town represented, I have come to the conclusion that the main difficulty with Zionism in America is the difficulty of finding an answer to the question:

"What can we as societies or as individuals do for Zionism?"

Perhaps you have already noticed something peculiar about the two questionswith which I have ended these two paragraphs. If you have not, look at themagain, because I do not wish to insult yourintellect by putting two and two togetherfor you. * * * Now don't they fit together like two halves of a broken stick?

The fact is that non-political preparation of the Jewish people for the goal of Zionism must be undertaken by the local proups and by individuals. To say nothing of the preparation that each Zionist may give himself or herself—and it would certainly be a magnificent cause for congratulation if every Zivnist were a prepared man or woman in_ the broadest sense—the preparation of others is of tremendous importance. I sometimes think that it would have been a great misfortune if the Jews could have gotten a Jewish Stete for the mere asking,. for many would have gone there without any national consciousness developed, without the beginnings of a new national art or literature, and with religious thought in such a condition that a religious Babel would probably have resulted. It would have been eonsiderehly worse than taking the Dor IIammidbar into the promised land. The men who make a nation must have definite ideals, firm faith and a degree of mutual understanding which Zionism can effect, should effect and, I may say, is effecting. For Zion’s sake when the yom haggadol, the great occasion, comes, let us not be found unprepared, with the hearts of the fathers still unturned to the sons, and the hearts of the sons still unturned to the fathers, lest, as the last of Israel’s prophets expresses it in his very last words, the land he smitten with a curse. Our endeavor should be to turn Jewish thought,