The Maccabaean · Vol. XI, No. 2 · August 1906
84printed page
scan 26 of 48
84
THE MACCABAEAN.

in the main, rather to the Minsk school than to any other. Yet, at the recent conference of the Soc.-Ter. in Europe, the representatives of the American Soc.-Ter., not feeling themselves strong enough to take a stand of their own, declared for the theories and ideas of the S. S., simply because the latter are the strongest of the S. T. organizations and because they happened to call for a conference first.

We now come to the parties within the Palestinian wing of socialists. The party that plays the most important part is certainly the Russian Poaley Zion. As orthodox Marxists they also, like the S. S., come to Zionism from the standpoint of histori- eal materialism. Yet the national question as such seems to be nearer to their hearts than to those of the S. S., although as Social-Democrats they handle this tender question cautiously, because, they maintain, the most advanced thought of mankind has not yet defined the relation of nationalism to the progress of humanity.

In the question of the relation of the various Jewish classes to nationalism, the Russian Poaley Zion takes almost the same stand as the S. S., but as the former develop their views much more clearly than the latter, let me give here a brief review of them:

The interest of the various Jewish classesin nationalism is not equal. The upperbourgeois class, that controls the market ofthe world, is, like the upper bourgeois classof all other nationalities, thoroughly cosmopolitan, and therefore opposed to nationalism. The middle Jewish bourgeois,depending economically upon the internalmarket of the country in which they live,tend to assimilate with the people of thatcountry were it not for the repelling forcewith which they meet in the rivalling bourgeois class of that nationality. And thesmall Jewish bourgeois, as is the case withthat of all other nationalities, is steadilydriven to the ranks of the proletariat, andthese in their turn, carry the whole burdenof the economic pressure borne down uponthe Jewish people, as they have a powerfulrival in the local proletariat, who, coming

chiefly from the village, is physically stronger and more easily satisfied as regards wages than the Jewish proletariat. This fact together with the hatred felt for the Jewish people, makes the existence of the Jewish proletariat unbearable in the countries where the Jews are densely populated and constitute the cause for its migrations, which if directed to a center where the Jews could in time form a majority and there create a national economy of their own, would do away with all these evils both for the Jewish bourgeois and for the Jewish proletariat. As it is, the migration at present tends, to be sure, to create Jewish centers in the new countries, but the Jews as such, not controlling the resources of those countries, merely bring with them the conditions of the countries from which they migrated.

This argumentation leads the Russian Poaley Zion to the idea of the necessity of a territory for the Jewish people. For Palestinism they declare themselves—as much as there is to learn from their still incomplete program—from the same point of view as a non-committal Zionist would do, who holds concentration of the Jews in their land to be a more direct road leading to ultimate freedom and independence than diplomatic negotiations. Therefore, I do not find it necessary to go into more details regarding it.

Another party of the Poaley Zion in Russia, is the "Seymovtzy," i. e., those who declare themselves for the Seym or as they recently styled themselves, "The Jewish Socialist Party." As they differ from the "Vozrozhdentzy," mentioned above, only in that they consider Palestine, and no other country, to be the final solution of the Jewish question,—and from the Russian Poaley Zion they differ in that they regard active work in Palestine before the decision of the Seym, futile, if not dangerous. I shall not dwell upon their theory any longer.

It the Seymovtzy agree with the Russian P. Z. in all but present work in Palestine, the "Hatchiyah" and the "Zeirey