The Maccabaean · Vol. XI, No. 2 · August 1906
82printed page
scan 24 of 48

the higher bourgeois class, desiring to keep up its position in society, tends towards assimilation with the non-Jewish bourgeois, whereas the smaller bourgeois, being pushed out of the market, are proletarising, that is, are going over to the productive class. And thus the Jewish proletariat, burdened by his own peculiar problem, his struggle for existence is constantly made harder for him by the rapid swelling of his ranks from the bourgeois class. For this misery of the Jewish proletariat, Zionism promises a radical remedy, by tending to create a national economy for the Jewish people of their own. Zionism, however, in its inception a movement for the proletariat, soon degenerated, in its first stages, because of the lack of self-consciousness among the latter at that time, into Hibbath Zion, a movement of the bourgeois, with whom it was not a question of life or death, but sprang from certain mystic yearnings for the restoration of Judaism to its old prestige. And it is only in the political and economic movements of political Zionism, that the Jewish proletariat, whose self-consciousness is now rising, that he finds again the true solution of the problem.

In how far this original conception of Jewish history and this theory of the development of Zionism is correct, is not here the place to discuss. Suffice it to say that this has become the starting points of almost all radical movements in Zionism of our day, defined according to the orthodoxy of the Marxistic theory of historical materalism or departure from it, prevailing in the various organizations. Besides the main division of the Zionist-Socialists of our day into the groups of Palestinians and Territorialists, there are three or more currents of ideas or theories within each group, from which point of view they reach Palestinism or Territorialism.

As the S. S. (Socialist-Zionists, a Territorialist organization in Russia, its initials being in Russian two S's), have developed perhaps most closely along the lines of the Heruthists, let me take them up first.

The point of view of the S. S. is purely Marxistic, perhaps more so than that of Marx himself. They absorb the philosophy of Jewish history advanced by the Heruthists into their own system, in which they go, however, beyond it. They also maintain that the Jewish proletariat has a special problem of his own, different from that of the international proletariat, a problem that could not be solved by the juridic adjustment of the rights of the Jewish people, pointing to the fact that even in countries where the Jews have political equality, as in Austria, the Jewish proletariat is not materially better off than in countries where the Jews are not given equal rights, a fact proving that the problem of the Jewish proletariat lies deeper than in the political inequality of the Jewish people.

The Jewish proletariat, the S. S. insist further—and here lies the focus of their territorialistic doctrine—the Jewish proletariat cannot fulfill, by his present social seclusion, the mission of the proletariat, he cannot serve both as a destructive power and a constructive force. At most he can be only a force assisting in the destruction of the old system of society, but he does not possess the constructive elements, not living under conditions which would give him the opportunity to proletarise and industrialise himself normally. In order to become constructive and assist in the building up of the future social state, the Jewish proletariat must live under conditions of a national economy of his own, which is only possible in a territory where the Jews would form a majority. Territorialism is then for the Jewish proletariat not the maximum but the minimum of his demands, i. e., it is not an end in itself but a means by which to reach to a normal proletarization and thus attain to the highest aim of the proletariat, Socialism.

Going out from this standpoint of "Classenkampf," on the one hand, without regard to Nationalism, and on the other hand, still holding to the somewhat supernatuated theory of Political Zionism, that a charter is a "conditio sine qua non," or