The Maccabaean · Vol. XI, No. 2 · August 1906
80printed page
scan 22 of 48
80
THE MACCABAEAN.
Radical Movements in Zionism

THERE were times when Socialism was considered primarily a cosmopolitan movement. This conception goes back probably to a declaration made by the founders of scientific socialism, Marx and Engels, in their “Manifesto of the Communists,” that the Proletariat does not give preference to any Fatherland, because he has none, and because he is, in his make-up, indifferent to patriotism. And this declaration, true to a certain extent of the political passivity of the proletariat of the time when the manifesto was issued, in 1847, was misinterpreted and misconstrued into a theory of denationalisation of its own. For if it is true that the proletarians did not take part, up to that time, in the shaping of the political situation of their respective nationalities, it was because they did not possess the power, because previous to the French revolution, the feudal lords and then the bourgeoisie deprived the proletariat of the right of participation in the political life of the nation. On the other hand, it has been this fourth, or, in modern times, the third, estate, which has always formed the backbone of the nation, which has expressed most distinctly its national charac- ‘teristics and kept them intact, whereas. it was the upper and middle classes that were most inclined to assimilation. And when in modern times the self-consciousness or the “Classen-bewustsein”’ of the proletariat has been aroused, there awakened within him also a national consciousness, and we find him now fighting in the first ranks not only for personal liberty but for the cultural, eeonomic and _ politi- eal independence of his ‘respective nationality. And according to the transformation in the political situation of the proletariat, the socialistic theories have al- ao been revised in this respect. As regards, therefore, the psychology and the national problem of the proletariat, the theories of the later teachers of Socialism are the truer.

This process was particularly noticeable

It was not, however, the revised views of their non-Jewish comrades that correc-ed those of the Jewish Socialists regarding Jewish Nationalism; it was life itself that brought them to it. But the process of this change of view was slower with the Jewish Socialist leaders, a fact that is due partly to the position of the Jews among the nations, and partly to their own pyschology as a party. Being bourgeois themselves, the Jewish Socialists could easily absorb the culture of the Jewish neighbors, and with this, the tendency of assimilation took strong hold upon them. For them, then, the problem of the Jewish proletariat was not a peculiarly Jewish one, but it lay within the sphere of that of the proletariat of the nationality among whom they lived, and the Jewish nation was for them either non-existent or else it was to serve as fertilizer for socialism.

It is an incredible but a well-known fact that the first appeal to massacre the Jews in Russia was issued by a party of Jewish Socialists, "Narodnvoltzy" in Kieff, with the purpose of awakening the self-consciousness of the Russian proletariat. It was life itself, then, that has gradually changed these bookish theories of the Jewish Socialists into sound views of Jewish life; for when these Socialists, big with European culture and socialistic ideas, came back to the Jewish masses to preach to them self-consciousness and "Classen-bewustsein," they hit here upon a hard rock, not easily to be dissolved in the waters of their assimilatory ideas. They found that besides class interests, the Jewish proletariat had his national interests which made his own problem distinct from that of his non-Jewish neighbors and that he feels and thinks Jewishly. The theories of the Socialists had, therefore, to be revised and for cosmopolitanism, internationalism had to be substituted in their program.