Jew merits and must have his self-hood. must retain his individuality, is beyond question. He has the fundamental biological endowment and the transcendent efficiency of moral function which are the ethical conditions of such self-maintenance. This is the sufficient answer to those who argue assimilation as the most facile untying of our Gordian knot, and if they hold it not sufficient let them remember that the Jew can not be assimilated, that history shows him to assimilate, that for some deep natural reason he is biologically an absorber, not of the absorbed. It is the Jew that dominates in the child of a mixed marriage, and after a few generations, if sterility does not supervene, as it usually does, what is not Jewish dies out or is transmuted. (Talko Rhynsiewicz, Ikof, Weissenberg). To preach assimilation is to preach the absurd and is an unworthy abasement, possibly only to the spiritually degenerate.
Nor is the Cultur-Zionism of AchadHaam much better than assimilation. Itis at its best only an intensification of thestatus quo. Its program does indeed recognize the function of the Jewish spiritin making for the moralization of theworld, but such an envisagement of therace's spirit in art and letters as a fulfillment of its program would be, could behardly more than mangy, a bit distrait,of the chameleon quality. For a people'sindividuality can not receive its highestand most adequate expression where individuality is a danger and a threat, as itmust be under an alien environment; andwhen, as in these pursy times, the criss-cross of influence is such that at few pointsdo its lines fail to touch each other, suchan expression can not be truly representative on any but a native soil, under nativelaws, amid native institutions. A cultural center under any other conditionscan be little more than artificial, a make-believe.
What is demanded for this most essential thing in a race's life, the expression of its spirit, the envisagement of its moral
ideal in art and letters, so that it shall give itself to the world's service to the uttermost of its self-hood, is that which M. Leroy Beaulieu tells us is a foremost factor in maintaining social solidarity—the permanent occupation of a definite territory. What is demanded is an absolute freedom for the play of the Jewish individuality, for the redintegration of the Jewish soul, for the intensification of the Jewish self-hood, for the emphasis and projection of what is most characteristically Jewish by the free struggle of Jew with Jew. For genuinely Jewish culture, which shall have the functional efficacy in the world which had the culture represented in the word Bible is impossible without a distinctively national life on a permanently occupied and definite territory under customs and law spiritually native. National self-expression assumes only on national life; what else there is may be interesting but remains secondary.
This, the leader and master of us all, Theodore Herzl, understood. And later he understood also that the particular territory upon which the race was to renationalize itself was not of great consequence. Be the land suitable for human life, it is enough; existence and autonomy upon it will rejuvenate the race's body and renew its spirit's health. A speedy restoration is what is essential, for indeed it is for many of us the eleventh hour and if the soul of us be not strengthened we shall die. That this restoration shall be to the land of our affection and our prayers; to the cradle of our race's development and the nurse of the race's soul, is natural and just. But though the cradle be roomy enough and the nurse kind enough one is not forever to be cradled and eternally to be nursed. And when the cradle is seized of alien hands and is defiled, and when the nurse is captive to ravishers, and it must be long ere the cradle can be retaken and cleansed and the nurse liberated and restored, then, be it remembered, the homing soul must create its home of a new place, even a wilderness, and must look to the sanity of its mind and body
