The Maccabaean · Vol. XI, No. 1 · July 1906
54printed page
scan 60 of 76
Facsimile · scan 60 of 76
Scan of p. 54
Text · transcribed from the scan

feelings of piety and of sympathy are awakened, and some will surely get so far as completely to affiliate themselves with us.

Especially in America, where sound practical sense has always forced ideal endeavors more into the background, we can expect larger and more permanent results for Zionism only then, if we bring concrete work in Palestine into the foreground and talk more of enterprises in the present than of hopes for the future.

Work in Palestine, however, is not to be recommended for reasons of utility alone; but —and I should like to emphasize this particularly—it is a natural consequence of the inner development of Zionist thought. If the demand for practical work in Palestine has, in recent days, become ever more insistent, we should regard this as a reaction against the so-called "political" Zionism, as is done in certain quarters. It is, on the contrary, a further development of this "political" Zionism.

The desire to unfold a practical activity in Palestine rests, in part, without doubt, upon the undeniable need of Zionists to be active, not only and exclusively in the service of agitation and of collection of money for a far-off future; but also to co-operate in a tangible matter whose development can be followed, even though this development be slow. On the other side, however, the opinion is being the more widely held, that political activity can only then be successful, if the necessary preparatory steps of a commercial nature be made. In order to engage in important politics, it is necessary to take advantage of the political situation; and the political situation is nothing more than the result of the activity, chiefly commercial, which has gone before. Storming a fortress can only then be sucesssful if the commanding outposts be taken after tiresome preparatory labor, if the trenches be dug and all preparations for the attack be made. Only if the heavy battery of commercial preparation in Palestine create a breach, has the storming of important politics any chances of success. Of course, commercial activity will have to be assisted by a parallel political action. Large results, however, will presumably only then be possible, if the Powers can be shown that Palestine can become not alone a Jewish sphere of influence in the future, but that it already is such as a matter of fact.

Formerly, the objection was made to practical work in Palestine that, under the present circumstances, commercial activity in Palestine must remain unfruitful, for, without a public and legal guarantee, no progress could be thought of in Turkey. The last few years, on the contrary, have shown such significant marks of progress in Turkey —it is necessary only to study the consular reports—that the dogma of the impossibility of commercial progress under the present circumstances can no longer be upheld. If nothing were to be gotten in Turkey, a contest of the various nations, such as is now going on, would not be thinkable. They are all trying to get a firm commercial footing there. These endeavors are, to be sure, supported by the various Governments for political reasons; but they are, besides that, undertaken and carried out by individuals, syndicates and banks, for purely financial reasons

From an entirely different point of view, i. e., from the point of view of those who admit the possibility of commercial development in Palestine, two other objections are often offered to such work on our part. In the first place, it is said, we dare not make Palestine valuable because then the Sultan would be all the less disposed to give the land to us. This objection has its basis in the conception, that the Sultan is to make a present of Palestine—something, however, which is asked by no one and can be expected by no one. It is not a matter for us of the separation of Palestine from the Turkish Empire, but of the winning of certain privileges, of a kind of local antomony. If England gives a charter to the South African Company or the Niger Company, it makes a present of the land just as little as Germany made a present of New Guinea and East Africa to the New Guinea Company, and to the German East Africa Company when it gave these companies charters. Granting, however, that the yearly or, at least, the periodic payments of a chartered company to the chartering government would be greater in the event that the land be commercially developed; it must not be