The Maccabaean · Vol. XI, No. 1 · July 1906
53printed page
scan 59 of 76
53
THE MACCABAEAN.
Palestine Questions

Address delivered at the Tenth Annual Convention of the German Zionists, June 5, 1906

Zionism, in so far as it concerns itself with work in Palestine, has two sources—the one constantly flowing, and the other intermittent. These sources are, devotion to Palestine on the one hand, and Jewish misery on the other. The first, in pre-Zionist times too, has always worked for Palestine; but this work was of a different kind from that of the present day, and until only a short time ago, it was altogether disorganized, and it suffered chiefly from the fact that it had its basis in charity. Jewish misery, on the other hand, regarded Palestine only as an eventual means of relief. For this reason, the stream flowing to Zionism from this source, is an uncertain one, often drying up whenever Jewish misery becomes less insistent or whenever new possibilities for emigration present themselves, or whenever there is a chance of attaining local autonomy in other places than in Palestine, or finally, whenever the political activity in behalf of Palestine shows gains which are too insignificant and too slow.

This intermittent source, with its springs in Jewish misery, is to be found chiefly in the lands of assimilation; that is, in Western Europe and America. The other source, devotion to Palestine, however, flows wherever there are pious Jews and wherever Jews have a national point of view; especially, therefore, in Eastern Europe. There the Jews are ready to make any sacrifice for Palestine. In the lands of assimilation, on the other hand, persons outside of the relatively narrow circles already mentioned as existing in these lands, take an interest in Palestine only from a certain piety on the one hand; and on the other hand, because men have the hope of creating for the unhappy East European Jews, a home in the Orient or in Palestine.

If we wish that our movement in the West should not remain confined to the small circle of those already devoted to Zionism, a circle which remains small in spite of all our efforts, we must endeavor to reckon with the feelings of those who, I would almost say, people the hunting grounds of Zionism, that is, of those persons who have had the contact with Palestine only by reason of piety or by reason of Jewish misery. It would, without doubt, be the simplest and best thing were we able to bring these people a charter for Palestine as a dowry; but it is not dependent upon us to determine the time when this will be possible Until that time, however, many who are affiliated with us, merely with the expectation of greeting this great movement, will undoubtedly fall away from us, and in indeed more than we shall be able to win. For those who are the more easily susceptible to our ideas are already in our ranks; and those who are still without our ranks are the more difficult to convince, with the exception, it may be, of some of the younger elements of the coming generation.

But our movement would grow tremendously if the possibility presented itself to us to win for our endeavors the less idealistic, that is, persons who are sober and with practical minds; for there is no doubt that in these classes of the Jewish people there is much energy, knowledge, and besides that, also capital and influence. These circles are not susceptible to ideas alone and to hopes for the future alone. But they may be won by sober figures and practical propositions. If we were able to place before them objects the soundness of which has been tested, they will surely take a part in these matters in large numbers. We see this, for example, in "Bezalel," which society, although due to Zionist initiative, is being supported for the most part by non-Zionists. If, indeed, such societies as the one mentioned, are not as yet altogether Zionistic, they come at any rate, by reason of participation in such endeavors, into contact with Zionist ideas, they lose their prejudices against the movement which had been represented to them heretofore as Utopian; and, with many, slumbering