The Maccabaean · Vol. XI, No. 1 · July 1906
18printed page
scan 24 of 76
18
THE MACCABAEAN.

boy, Paterson, Philadelphia, Providence,Pittsburg, Stanford, St. Louis, Trentonand Utica.

To be sure, quite a number of meetings were held throughout the country which were arranged by societies and councils without the co-operation of the Propaganda Committee. Of these no complete record is obtainable, though efforts have been made in that direction and will be persisted in. It is necessary that the Federation should know of all public meetings, no matter how large or how small, that are held for Zionist purposes, in order that we shall know how our movement is progressing and what its condition is in the various Jewish centres of the country. Without this knowledge the work of the Propaganda Committee, must, necessarily, be hampered. A proper propaganda, conducted under the most favorable auspices, would be one that would be thoroughly acquainted with all of the strong and with all of the weak centres; especially the latter. This would give the Propaganda Committee the desired opportunity to raise the movement throughout the country to the highest level, and to stimulate Zionists to greater activity. It would then also know what methods are good, and what methods are bad, and what should be discarded and what modified to meet certain conditions.

The Propaganda Committee has also been handicapped by wandering speakers styling themselves Zionist agitators. These men, for the most part irresponsible and unscrupulous, go from city to city and from town to town, deliver what they are pleased to term Zionist addresses, either charging an admission fee, or prevailing upon individuals to organize themselves into committees for the collection of as much money as the city or town will give for the privilege of having listened to their harangues. It happened that some of these charlatans, who have only the interest of their pockets at heart, and use our cause as a mean of livelihood, have been aided in their business by local Zionists and Zionist societies. The Propaganda Committee wishes to point out that it is nec-

essary that every possible step should be taken against these men. Nothing can be done in cities and towns where there are no organized Zionist societies; but they can be silenced wherever there is a Zionist organization. It must be borne in mind that every dollar which these men obtain on the pretense that they are Zionist agitators, is so much money practically stolen from the various funds of our movement. After two or three of these charlatans have exploited a community, that community is- either in no condition or is disinclined to give any money for legitimate Zionist purposes. It has been suggested that Zionist societies in towns where these men come should enter into a dicker with them, to wit: that these men shall be compelled to agree to turn over part of their receipts to the local society for its own purpose or for the National Fund. The Propaganda Committee is strongly opposed to any such dicker, because it would mean a certain sanction for men of whom we know nothing good, and in many cases, know much that is bad. The Propaganda Committee is glad to announce that it has succeeded in silencing at least one of these charlatans, and it asks now for the co-operation of the societies and of all Zionist in its work of silencing all of them. That a man has a right to make a living is not denied, but Zionists must oppose any and every attempt to make a living at the expense of the movement.

The Propaganda Committee has found that the present limitations of its scope do not tend toward making its work most efficient. The Propaganda Committee should be empowered to arrange for meetings and to follow up these meetings: that is, it should not be required to wait until a society or council desires to hold a meeting, and to limit its activity to such places where there are societies and councils; nor should its work be at an end when the meeting had been held and a report of the meeting filed. Its work should really begin after the meeting has been held: that is, it should endeavor to gain the last measure of usefulness to the movement