The Maccabaean · Vol. XI, No. 1 · July 1906
7printed page
scan 13 of 76
7
THE MACCABAEAN.
The Legalization of the National Fund

It is a truism of politics that any Government—even a bad one—is better than no Goverment. So, in a People's movement, like Zionism, any Constitution is better than no Constitution; in the care and disposition of its Funds any form of legalisation is to be preferred to an entire absence of legal control. Yet the historical development of the "National Fund"—the peculium of the Jewish people—has been such that in the fifth year of its existence it is still a shapeless instrument, a creation which from the legal point of view is "without form and void," and darkness hovers over it depths.

That this is so is not the fault of the People, for the question has been raised in every Congress; nor is it entirely the fault of the leaders, for there has never been a time when the settlement of a constitution of some sort for the Fund has not been the subject of their earnest consideration; and to the drafting of Schemes there has been no end.

The initial error which separated the National Fund from the National Trust— declared on its origination to be “the financial instrument of Zionism”—which set it up as, in some degree, a rival competing for the contributions of the People towards the main national object, which claimed for it the status and privileges of a “juridical person” to enable it to carry on its operations as an independent organization whilst yet remaining an integral part of the machinery of the movement vitiated all endeavours to establish the legal entity contemplated by the promoters, in which the freedom of action of the private benefactor was to be combined with all the limitations of a special endowment.

The complexity of the situation thus created was aggravated by the invitation and receipt of contributions on the

strength of mere Resolutions of Congress for the establishment of a National Fund before any legal basis had been found for it, and before any but the most general idea had been formed of the conditions under which the Fund should be applied, of the methods by which it should be controlled, or even of the persons by whom it should be administered.

The popular tendencies towards “action” which brought about these results came into sharp conflict with the restraining influences of legal caution (which had previously kept the fluctuating schemes for a separate National Fund within due bounds), at the Congress of 1901.

Proposals for the immediate establishment of this “money-box of the Jewish people” (eines Sparpfennigs fur das judische Volk) then brought forward, and earried, after a spirited discussion in which all the objections which have since proved themselves to be so well founded were urged, by a bare one-tenth vote in a meeting of some 200 delegates. The Resolutions thus adopted declared the objects of the Fund as follows :—

"The Jewish National Fund shall be the inviolable property of the Jewish people and shall be used only when an amount to be determined by the Congress (some £200,000), has been reached, but exclusively for the purpose of purchasing land in Palestine and Syria.

The application of the fund shall be proceeded with in such manner as to permit the using of one-half of the said amount for purchasing land, while the other half must remain invested at interest. Subsequently one-half of the further amount collected each year for the National Fund may be (but need not necessarily be) used for the pur-