The Maccabaean · Vol. XI, No. 1 · July 1906
5printed page
scan 11 of 76

like them he revolts, after having received a broader sweep of knowledge and culture, against its autocratic hold of the Jewish mind and life,—indirectly involving in his revolt the ruin of a young, innocent wife, married in his days of ignorance. But there is in the make-up of the hero of “Whither?” something that stamps him as an original creation, and, at the same time, as a child of the transition period in the history of European Jewry,—a period running half-ways into our own. For Nahman is not like the heroes of the Haskalah period, a creature worked upon from outside, by alien culture and influences. Such influences came upon him, when he was already deep in revolt. He is a character, a hero of his own making. He is the traditional Acher, who “ventured into Paradise—the Jewish Paradise—alive, observed, and staggered,” for it was Jewish ideas themselves, Jewish thought and philosophy, that, in their inconsistency, gave Nahman food for his profane and blasphemous meditations. And then, after his eyes had finally been opened to the beauties and his mind to the thoughts of the outside world, and coming then to compare notes with the undersized Hebrew literature—obviously that of the Haskalah period,—what did he find there? He found it busied with “permitting pease on passover and denying the existence of angels and devils,” instead of leading the people to a new life and new ideas. His disappointment in the new thought of his people and his dissatisfaction with the stagnant life around him, grew into morbidness and madness.

Thus far, Feierberg succeeded in grasping the spirit of the transition period in Jewish history, in the history of Eastern Jewry, and gave the life picture of it in his hero Nahman, in his own life’s history, if you will. For who is Nahman, if not Feierberg himself, with his experience in life, with his fragile body, eternal, with his preference and partiality for the old mediaeval masters of Jewish thought? And what are Nahman’s adventures in life—if passive incidents and accidents be called

so if not, with some shifting of scenery and substitution of this or that circumstance, those of Feierberg own history?

And finally, the climax of the story and the attempt at solving the historic problem. Amid this mental suffering of the hero, Nahman, there looms upon the horizon the new idea, the idea of the Jewish national revival—deviously in the Chibbath-Zion form. This worked as a temporary tonic on his diseased mind. For a moment he clutched it convulsively, his eyes dilated and his pulse began to beat faster. Will this idea make life worth living? Surely, “in the long panegyrics of the land and its future,” he did not find what he wanted, he was disgusted to hear their misinterpretation of the value of the idea,—as if the whole question were merely of immediate material significance! As if the whole problem was only that of “bread in adversity and water in oppression.” But Nahman worked out his own solution, and he delivered himself of it one day, at the first outburst of enthusiasm that the idea had evoked from the people of his town, in the form of a public meeting.

“The Jewish people,”—he said,—“always participated in all world-movements. . . . Every great period in Jewish history falls within the limits of a great period in general history. . . Here is, however, the Roman period. At that time, dusk began to set in upon the East, while the dawn appeared in the West. The Greeks were the first to bring about the destruction of the East and to build the West upon its ruins. And together with the whole East fell also the glory of the Judean people. This great movement was not the movement of the word but that of the spirit. . . Every great historic movement was that of the spirit. Mankind cannot exist without an ideal. . . But the ideals created by its great men cannot live forever. The farther the prophet penetrates into the dark future, the greater and the more durable is the ideal that he creates. . . But after all even such an ideal is not everlasting. Mankind suddenly becomes