tone has been improved another should be started and the process repeated. It is highly important that the boys should be taken in young, during their last year at school, before they have had much freedom, and street cliques have begun to exist, and before the boys have gone out to work. There are some club managers, however, who confine the boys they admit to a certain district and play upon the street feeling to strengthen their club patriotism and club tone.
Though a boy will no longer find the same pleasure in playing at soldiers in the Brigade after the age of eighteen or nineteen, there is no reason why the Club should not be as attractive. It is a very simple matter to confine a room for seniors or even to hire the premises next door or down the street. It is merely a question of cost, and a successful club cannot be run on the cheap. After repeated failures with two or three boys, it is impossible to give up the chances of success, because the new plan will necessitate a small expenditure. To the stranger a few pictures or a cheery wall paper are an unnecessary extravagance, to the boy it gives the club an appearance of home and of welcome.
Before leaving this question of "Clubs," I wish to lay emphasis on the fact, that to the boys, the club is no charity and no medium of pauperization. The member pays a subscription to the club, usually one pence a week, which unhappily has hardly any effect on its finances, and for whatever he does in the way of extras, he has to pay a nominal charge, be it for the fare to football or swimming or a country ramble; or even for old clothes. This is highly important, for were it not so a club would not justify its existence. A boy would start his life on charity and on charity of the worst order, in getting for nothing what after all is not an absolutely necessary for life.
The result of a boys' club best worth having cannot be measured. To discuss the abstract question of what has been achieved, is like asking whether if a thing
had been otherwise the result would have been different. Go down any alley and ask your way—it will be a boy that you will ask, and it will be several boys that will answer. The boys have nowhere to go in the evenings. They are not wanted at home. The club then is the alternative of the street, and to justify its existence, it has only at the lowest to compare favorably with the street. The managers of such clubs, are the only people who know the boys when they come, and they are the only people who have a right to judge the results. The difficulties are countless, indifference, slackness, irregularity, want of work, with want of even the club penny, overtime, late hours, removal or loss of tried club members, quarrels between boys, the competition of the street, the more serious competition of gambling houses, the music hall, and the other sex. These are enough at times to try the most robust faith in clubs; for on the other side there is little to show—a few boys who have turned out right well—most a mere mediocrity—some a total failure. There will be the club captain, the trusted ally of the managers; the small boy who needs protection, and the boy from whom he needs to be protected; the dull-witted foreign boy, whom no game or jokes or geem to enliven; the club fool, that most difficult type, whose sin is to think he does no wrong, who thinks himself but is not thought funny; the club baby, the club toady, the club favorite—it is not without variety and interest this small republic of ours. You once belonged to it yourself. Will you not again become an older member?
But I do not wish it to be thought thatthe effect of the street is all bad. It is astrange mixture of good and evil. On thewhole its tendency is to raise not to lowerthe tone of action and thought.Though that strange law by whichthe moral ideas of a crowd are generally better than those of the individuals composing it, the street as awhole will often cry shame on act, whicheach person in the street if left alone
