the reconciliation of the Bible with Aristotle.
Jehudah Halevi, however, sees veryclearly that a positive religion cannot haveits source in an Aristotelian God. In sofar as Jehudah Halevi ascribed will toGod, making him first as well as finalcause of existence, he does no more thanwhat Maimonides himself felt compelledto do in justice to his Judaism, but Jehudah Halevi insists very much more strongly on the direct and essential communionof God with man, which alone makesrevelation possible, and he rejects thatconcept of the immortality of the soulwhich is a direct consequence of Greekintellectualism. According to Aristotle,(at least in scholastic interpretation) manwins immortality in so far as he becomesintellectually perfect and thus identifiedwith the Active Intelligence. Our authorasks with evident cynicism, why, if immortality be an acquisition, we might notestablish colleges set apart for the attainment of immortality.
Though Jehudah Halevi stigmatizedGreek thought as a culture rich in blossombut barren of fruit, he does not fail topay tribute to Aristotle as the "greatest ofthe wise," and feels convinced that, hadhe had the tradition of God's creation ofthe world, and had that Divine communionwhich manifests itself so wondrously inthe history of Israel entered the horizon ofhis vision, he would surely have succeededin giving them philosophical expression.
I mention these scattered points, incoherent though they may seem at first, to indicate in advance what general dogmatic limits we must expect to find in a philosophic work of this period, and at the same time to make clear the particular attitude to this Zeitgeist of the unique personality of Jehudah Halevi.
Now to resume our argument. Much to the surprise of the king of the Chazars, the Jew does not begin with an abstract argument for the belief in the existence of God or with a definition of Ethics, but with a declaration of faith in the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, and in the
Torah revealed to all Israel upon Sinai. That God communicates with man is not then the result of a theory about the Divine essence, but a concrete experience of the whole Nation, the foundation of all positive religions. If we admit God's potency in the creation of Nature, we must also concede the possibility of his turning it from its usual course in the interest of moral ends.
The voice created by God's will on Sinai, the tablets inscribed by some Divine mystery with the undying Law, are the undeniable evidences that God did communicate with man and did teach Israel the Torah.
Religion for the Jew is therefore fact and not hypothesis, an experience and not a creation.
It would show but poor insight into the system of our author’s thought, were we to brand him at once as a mere religious positivist. He sees very clearly that such a unique experience of the Divine presupposes a certain preparedness in man. The revelation calls for the prophet, be he individual or nation. Indeed it is his theory of inspiration which is the most original as well as the most profound contribution which our author makes to Jewish thought.
The treatment involves three subjects, a consideration of the general nature of Prophecy, a justification of Israel’s claim to be the nation of Prophecy, and an examination into the relation of the Holy Land to the prophetic inspiration of Israel.
What Jehudah Halevi says of the nature of Prophecy, as we have it from various parts of the book, bears witness to the spiritual insight he possessed. Prophecy, he urges, is no mere development of reason. Consider for a moment the four grades of being in the world—the inanimate, the vegetative soul of the plant, the passionate animal soul, and lastly the reasoning soul of man. In thought, project this reasoning soul onward to the uttermost limits of possible development. What have we then? A soul grown wiser