The Maccabaean · Vol. X, No. 5 · May 1906
187printed page
scan 27 of 50
Facsimile · scan 27 of 50
Scan of p. 187
Text · transcribed from the scan

has inspired our greatest thinkers, our sublimest poets, and has given strength to our strong men.

strong men.I grant that it would be inhuman to restrain those who are wearied of a burden to throw that burden off; and I am altruistic enough not to rebuke the Jew who is wearied of the Jewish burden if he seeks relief in suicide by assimilation. Judaism is the supreme test, determining better and more surely than any other test, who is fit to survive. One who wills not to survive is obviously unfit; therefore, his disappearance is a blessing, not an evil. But the strong and the fit in Israel are yet many, and as they will that Israel shall not disappear, Israel will exist.

If Israel is to exist, his existence must be a national one, for in no other way can his existence be continued. Nor is his existence in any other way desirable, either from Israel's viewpoint or the viewpoint of the world. A scattered nation is an anomaly, and the existence of a scattered nation must, necessarily, be abnormal. Such an existence must lead inevitably, as it has led in Israel's case, to a certain upsetting of balances, to an amount of friction between the scattered nation and the rest of the world. Prejudice, race-hate, discrimination and massacres find their logical source in this friction. To get this clear in your mind, picture the world as a vast machine operating for the accomplishment of a given task, whatever that task may be. Picture this machine with every wheel and every spring, every rod and every shaft, every bar and every bolt, each in its allotted place, and performing its function. Behold how smoothly and how surely this machine operates! Now, picture one wheel torn from its axis, and hurled into the rest of the machine. The machine, running so smoothly but a while ago, gives forth crashing noises; there is chaos. The wheel broken off is hurled hither and thither and yon, as it strikes against the other parts of the machine. Each part suffers damage, but the wheel flying aimlessly about in the machine is damaged most. Will it remedy matters

any, will the machine then run smoothly and continue to perform its task, to wait until the wandering wheel be pounded to atoms by the other wheels, and these atoms are assimilated with the natural waste of the machine? Will the machine perform its task without that wheel? Is not the remedy the restoring of the wandering wheel to its axis, thereby ending the abnormal and damaging friction and enabling the machine to resume the performance of its task?

This analogy, I venture, is clear and expresses in another form the thought in the mind of Anatole France, the distinguished leader of French culture, author, critic and political economist, when he said the other day:

"Let us preserve, respect and maintain these national organizations which in the present condition of humanity are for us the necessary forms of social life. Let us reflect that the disintegration of the free peoples, the downfall of the intellectual nations, far from precluding the union of the races thus released, would soon lead to a regime of barbarous autocracy over Latin Europe. The various nations must take their places in the universal federation as living and not as dead entities.

"It is through the qualities of the nations which have been faithful to their genius, respecters of others, respecters of themselves, that the dream of the old prophet of Israel will one day be fulfilled, when he spoke of the time when the swords shall be beaten into ploughshares, when the mountain of the Lord's house shall be established in the top of the Mountains, and all nations shall flow unto it; and many people shall go and say, Come ye, and let us go up to the mountains of the Lord. . and He will teach us of His ways and we will walk in His paths.

"When that day comes may we find France still in the full possession of her name, still mindful of herself, and with her power and genius undiminished.

"May that day find her erect upon the radiant summits of concord and peace, her brow wreathed with the olive branch, and