The Maccabaean · Vol. X, No. 5 · May 1906
186printed page
scan 26 of 50
186
THE MACCABAEAN.

States: “It is time for the unreserved acknowledgment that the toleration and equal opportunity accorded to the Jews of the United States have been abundantly repaid to us. And in making up the accounts, let us not omit to put to their credit the occasion presented to us through our concession to them of toleration and equality, for strengthening, by wholesome exercise, the spirit of broadminded justice and consideration, which, as long as we are true to ourselves, we must inflexibly preserve as the distinguishing and saving traits of our nationality.” Note the invidious distinctions made by Mr. Cleveland. The United States, he would have it appear, has conferred certain favors (of recognizing rights he does not speak) and this kindness has proved profitable. Note how he draws the line between the American people—“our nation” and “them”—the Jews.

Does the world wish to assimilate with us? Is the party of the second part willing to enter into the bonds of matrimony? Is it not high time that the spurned and bruised swain shall refuse to suffer rebuffs and humiliations more, and to display a proper spirit of self-respect?

But even if the world were willing, should we assimilate with it? Should we give up our separate existence and disappear? It would be a most cowardly act, indeed, if now, after having endured the horrors of the centuries, and having come to that point in our wanderings where we can, finally, make a stand and assert ourselves, we should commit suicide. We have a reason for being, a right to exist— nay, an imperative and undeniable responsibility for continued existence. More than any other people, we are the heirs of yesterday. We have a heritage which we are bound to accept and administer for the benefit of mankind in general, and for our own posterity in particular. The whole course of the Jewish events through the ages is the acceptance and administration of this heritage, though its acceptance has foredoomed thousands of our ancestors and myriads of our brethren to

persecution and death. To abandon it is to be untrue to that marvellous and inspiring history, which is the history of the Jews, and which makes it imperative that we shall continue to exist as a distinct nation.

For, indeed, we are a nation. Themental concept of a populated land, of aform of government, of means of defenseand offense, of a commerce, of a policepower, does not apply to the Jewish Nationat the present time; but a history, a common language, and obligations and privileges of citizenship do apply, and I submitthat these together with the fact that theJews are a collective individual, that is,they constitute a specially marked type,with special characteristics, special ways,special aims and ideals that clearly distinguish them from any other collective individual, are a reasonable foundation uponwhich to base a claim of nationality.

The all-important fact is that historically the Jews are a nation. Nationality has its mainspring in historical consciousness. The annihilation of the state does not annihilate this historical consciousness. So long as the history is there, so long as the consciousness of that history is present, the State may go—the State may be dismembered, divided among an hundred covetous Powers, the people may be driven from the land, but the nation exists.

"A nation, however, as it confronts themodern world is a purely spiritual product.Sometimes it has been born in independence, like Scotland; sometimes it has beenborn in dependence, in subjugation, likeIreland; sometimes it is a large thingcohering out of many smaller things, likeItaly; sometimes it is a small thing breaking from larger things, like Poland. Butin each and every case its quality is purelyspiritual, or, if you will, purely psychological." And this psychological something is historical consciousness.

This historical consciousness exists among the Jewish people; has, in fact, always existed. It has manifested itself at various times and in various ways. It