The Maccabaean · Vol. X, No. 5 · May 1906
177printed page
scan 17 of 50
177
THE MACCABAEAN.

after the highest ideal, and the proof of the matter is this very festival to-day, a reminder of the deeds of the Hasmoneans.'

Fadai had not finished his words when the house was in an uproar, and the rafters shook because of the shouts of applause. My wife saw the honor done to her son and was pleased. Every one was praising him with: 'Happy the mother who gave him birth'—and she was proud of him. I, too, felt honored by virtue of the honor shown him. Many surrounded me and shook hands with me and said: 'Happy art thou that this son has come from thy loins; may his like increase in Israel.'

“I stood speechless, thinking the while: How numerous thy works, Master of the World, and how great are the wonders which thou bringest to pass in the world. Who could have persuaded me that my son, Fadai, an 'assimilationist' from birth, who did not know his people, who never wanted to know his religion or a Hebrew letter,— that he would fight the fight of Israel, that he would speak so well, that he would become a defender of Judaism and wish for a redeemer for his nation!

"Many other speakers arose that evening. The rebirth of the Israelitish nation—that was the central point toward which all the speeches were directed, albeit by devious ways. Each one had his own opinion and sought to outdo his neighbor, so that they became noisy and enthusiastic and their words were as coals of fire. One excitable, fiery young man, in whom there were still many of the characteristics of a Yeshiba student, and who was a subtle pedant, speaking in the sing-song and lifting his thumb, took issue with my son:

"The opinion of Zarchi, the Mishna teacher: There shall be no saving of us children of Israel or of Judaism except by giving expression to our national genius. From his words the conclusion may be drawn that the object desired for our people is the elevation of our national spirit, and this is possible in any place, so that Zion is not an essential for him. He is therefore a Nationalist, but not a Zionist."

"Still another said:

"In order to save Judaism in its entirety, both its traditions and its literature—for it is these which form the real basis of our nationality—the Jews should not have a land of their own, but should dwell away from their own land. It would be impossible at the present day to have the civilization of a cultured people in the land of Israel based upon statutes and laws, which might have been well enough for days gone by, but which are radically different from those needed now. Large portions of Israel's Law would, therefore, be unobserved and would be forgotten together with the Bible itself, and many customs of worship and prayer and of family and communal life—these make up the body with whose passing the spirit too would be destroyed. We shall find that the rebirth of the land of Israel will mean the death of Israel itself. If we believe that Israel will awaken to new life upon its own soil, it will be a new Israel, without its written and traditional law, and without the practices and desires and feelings and all the other matters which are dependant upon these, and which give Israel its individuality now.'

“From this you can see that that evening was not taken up with cards and idle talk. They talked of the welfare of the community of Israel. Whose words were most convincing, is something I shall not undertake to decide now. For me they were all acceptable, because they came from the heart, and because all were imbued with love for their people.

“Now I knew what Fadai was and what his companions were, and it was clear to me that I had suspected them of things for which there was no warrant. Their desire was not to reform the world, but their people, to bring a new spirit into it—a knowledge of itself, of its honor and of its hope for the future, as well as the revival of its language, the language of its Tora and its ancient Prophets. They had not come to destroy, but to build, and to plant Israel upon the soil of its fathers. In our time we never knew these new types. They desire to bring the children, the branches loosened from the tree of Judah, back to