The Maccabaean · Vol. X, No. 4 · April 1906
124printed page
scan 8 of 54
Facsimile · scan 8 of 54
Scan of p. 124
Text · transcribed from the scan

Palestine, even the mystic speculation and sectarian differences had their home in Palestine. Our liturgy was formulated there, and our oldest liturgical poems which adorn our services were first written in Palestine. In fact, all spiritual food, after which the soul of man yearns, has been prepared there, and we have been fed by it as by the manna of old, through invisible hands and in growing richness throughout the ages. All this literary activity demonstrates, almost with mathematical precision, the fact that the Jews continued to live in sufficiently large numbers in Palestine, and that they not only devoted themselves to tilling the ground, but also found means and leisure to work in the field of spiritual developement and intellectual elevation, and thus made Palestine the spiritual centre for Judaism.

I will now endeavor, in general outline, to justify the preceding conclusions by facts which, scattered among the pages of Jewish historians, are now focussed here for the first time for the purpose of bringing home to Jews that new aspect of the Palestinian question which, to my knowledge , has never yet been attempted, viz., the continuity of Jewish life in Palestine from the time of the first conquest under Joshua unto this very day, the consciousness of our unchangeable rights to the possession of that country, and the central position and paramount importance which this continuity has had for the spiritual development of Judaism.

The fact is well-known that with the destruction of the Temple a large proportion of the Jewish population remained in Palestine. It was not transported to any other country, as was the habit and policy of other Eastern kings, and a school was opened in Jamnia under R. Johann ben Zakkai, substituting the spiritual Temple for the material and the prayer of the lips for the sacrifices in the now destroyed Temple. Outwardly that destruction had struck a blow at the religious sentiments of the people, but not to the national consciousness, as it is sometimes wrongly stated. For let us consider the mental

attitude of the people of the time. The temporal government was one which the people detested, for it was neither national nor justified by historical tradition. Both the Maccabæans and the Herodians were usurpers of the throne. It belonged rightly only to the descendants of the house of David. It made very little difference to the people who, for the time being, were the overlords, who managed the political government of the country. This is the reason why the people acquiesced in the Roman overlordship, so long as it did not touch the Temple, and for this reason they little bewailed the downfall of that hateful dynasty which, to them, was a family of Edomite usurpers. Totally different was the question of the Temple, which represented to them the medium of their relation with God, and its destruction was an unmistakable break in their direct relation with God, and, as it is put by the Midrash, signified a withdrawal of the Shekinah, of God’s visible glory, which no longer rested on the people. The Midrash goes on to say that the Shekinah migrated ten times from place to place until it ascended again up to heaven, and most of these places after it had left the Temple were the various school-houses or colleges erected by the heads of the nation in Jamnia, Usha, Sepphoris, and, finally, Tiberias. Translated into modern language, this means that no final break between God and His chosen people had taken place so long as their attachment to God's word remained true and uninfluenced by outward evil examples. Though longing for the rebuilding of the Temple, and praying for the future secular independence, they are contented to see the government pass practically into hands more readily acknowledged as authoritative by the people in Palestine and outside, for the descendants of the house of David are now heads of the Jewish nation; they are called Patriarchs, and they wield the power of a temporal government under the suzerainty of Rome. Now they work for maintaining their spiritual independence, and to deepen the feeling of national unity. Men like Gamaliel, Judah the Prince, and