diminish the weight of our claim. It is sufficient for one man to live on a land to represent a large number of owners who are living far away, and of such representatives we have never been lacking in sufficient numbers. Those who lived in Palestine were there in their own country, and they knew that they were trustees for the whole of the nation; they lived there, not only for their own sakes, but for the sake of Judaism and of the Jews outside. The citadel was not to be left without a garrison. A modern example shows that the number of inhabitants plays @ very insignificant role when it is a question of maintaining the moral claim to the land. At the dawn of the nineteenth century the number of Greeks that lived in ancient Greece was very small, indeed, nothing to be compared to the numbers of Greeks who lived in far distant lands, such as in Roumania, Asia Minor, and the West of Europe. Did any one for that reason ever impugn their claim when they started to fight against the Turks? And if their claim was respected, and they made their claim sword in hand, how much more must our claim be respected and _ recognized when we come with the olive branch in our hand or, better, with the ploughshare and pruning-hook! But there seems to be a great mistake in assuming that the number of Jews left behind in Palestine was very small. Some of the incidents which I shall mention in the course of this paper prove that it has been greatly underestimated. Every literary or political movement carried on on a large scale presupposes a strong backing by a large number of followers, and of adherents in the country. No one can suppose the existence of the Patriarchate with princely dignitaries, wielding great authority, which continued up to the middle of the fifth century in Palestine, without, at the same time, agreeing that Palestine could not have been entirely depopulated or completely devastated by Rome. The res*zic- tive legislation of MHadrian and afterwards of the Christian emperors, Constantine, Justinian, and others, or the attempted rebuilding of the Temple in
Jerusalem in the year 361 by the Emperor Julian, all these go to prove that the vast majority of the inhabitants, or, at any rate, a considerable proportion of the inhabitants of Palestine, must have been Jews. The belief in the absence of Jews from Palestine rests, as a rule, upon reports of a late age or upon the very scant information gleaned from the pages of the Christian pilgrims to the Holy Land, who shunned, as much as possible, any contact with Jews, or from Jewish travellers of the twelfth and thirteenth centuries, after the Crusaders had swept over the land, and had brought the whole country to the verge of ruin. But a moment's reflection will alter that estimate. For has Palestine been barren for twelve hundred years? Are there no other records of the intervening period? Those who continued to live on the soil of Palestine, ignored by their brethren in the Diaspora, did they merely vegetate, or did they, on the contrary, display an intense spiritual activity which made them the true representatives of the Jewish nation and tradition? For what makes the soil of Palestine still more sacred to us than the notion that it is closely entwined with our religious and national aspirations, that the tradition which moulded our life in the rest of the world had its root and justification in the tradition which was first formulated and fixed by our teachers and sages of Palestine? That tradition has never been broken, nor has anyone denied that it was the highest expression of Judaism, inspired by the memories of the days of yore, and by the hopes of the future.
To anticipate here some of the results —if we turn to the whole range of Jewish life, there is scarcely one single element in it that is not dependent on the work performed by Jews in Palestine after the destruction of the second Temple. Our Bible, as far as the text with all its Massoretic tradition is concerned, has been fixed in Palestine, the Oral Law has been codified in Palestine, the interpretation of both written and oral traditions starts from Palestine, the calender by which we regulate our festivals was established in