The Maccabaean · Vol. X, No. 4 · April 1906
122printed page
scan 6 of 54
Facsimile · scan 6 of 54
Scan of p. 122
Text · transcribed from the scan

and lastly the conquest by the Turks, which brings us down to the year 1799, when the French and English fought their battle before Acre.

But all these are not my concern, all these form part of general history, the history of the world, and affect very little Palestine in its relation to Jews and Judaism. The question which I will endeavor to answer is: have we ever relinquished our claim to the land in face of these succeeding conquerors; has the Jewish conscience ever cut itself adrift from the intimate connection with the land; have we ever denied the hope of regaining it once more with the political status of ancient times? To be driven away by force is not the same as giving up by one's own free will, and the right which belonged to us 2,000 years ago has not been forfeited, because we have not been able to exercise it in a political sense in face of adverse circumstances and overwhelming inimical forces.

My object in giving this paper is to describe as briefly as possible the relation in which the Jews stood to Palestine and Palestine to the Jews during that period of time, and to show that the land was known to us in the fullest sense of the word only by the name of Erez Israel, the Land of Israel. This name may sometimes vary, and the land may be called the "Holy Land," or by some other poetical equivalent, but to the Jewish conscience it was the "Land of Israel," the only land of Israel. But Jews did not only claim it from a distance: it will be my aim to show that the Jews have continued to live there all through the times, and even in spite of dire oppression they clung to the land, and unless driven away by force, gravitated towards it; they would not willingly exchange it for any other more alluring, and with greater advantage for their physical well-being. Nay, the contrary has constantly been the case. People in high positions, and with affluent means, whenever possible, found it a privilege to emigrate there, and to live there a life which they considered to be more worthy, more in harmony with their own

tradition. Up to this very day, it is sufficiently well known that, if not allowed to live, people go there to die, for there they are "at home," and they prefer that their body should mix with the dust out of which their forefathers had been moulded. Does this not prove that to the Jewish conscience the absence of political life in Palestine was considered merely a temporary phase in the evolution of Jewish history, and that, in the long run, this also must come to pass, for it had been foretold by the prophets, and there was the oath which God swore to their ancestors, an oath which stands for ever! All through the ages this claim has been maintained. Wherever Jews lived they were made to feel that they were strangers, wandering footsore from land to land, everywhere aliens, living on sufferance, only Palestine was their true home. Nor has ever a Christian or Mohammedan denied our claim to Palestine. This sorry privilege has been left to Jews, who are busily inventing excuses for obliterating Palestine from the memory and consciousness of the Jews, and who do not scruple to renounce any and every claim, if, by so doing, they could win the applause of their non-Jewish neighbors. It is a futile endeavor, and brings only contempt on those who expatriate themselves from a Holy Land, and are not allowed to share in the patrimony of others. If we have not renounced Palestine, has Palestine renounced us? Has it only been a pious and sentimental memory, or have the ties which unite us to that land remained unbroken? Have we continued to live on the soil of Palestine? Has Palestine still continued to exercise any influence upon Jewish life since the fall of the Temple? Has it continued all through the centuries to be the very heart of Jewry? Such are the questions which I purpose to answer. In the first place, Jewish occupation of the country has remained unbroken, I may say, to this very day. It is not a question of numbers, and whether the Jews that have lived during that period in Palestine have been very few or many makes no difference. Numbers neither increase nor