be no longer: eternally despised Jews.
We have lately had very bitter experiences in Russia. That country has toomany and too few of us; too many in thesouthwestern provinces, in which the Jewsare allowed to reside, and too few in all theothers, in which they are forbidden to reside. If the Russian government, and theRussian people as well, realized that anequal distribution of the Jewish populationwould inure only to the benefit of the entire country, the persecutions which wehave suffered would probably not have takenplace. But, alas, Russia cannot and willnot realize this. That is not our fault,neither is it a consequence of the low cultural status of the Russian people; we havefound our bitterest opponents, indeed, in alarge part of the press, which ought to beintelligent; the unfortunate situation of theRussian Jews is due, rather, purely and simply to the operation of those general forcethe consequences of the nature of humanity, which we have previously discussed.Accordingly, as it is not to be our task toimprove the human race, we must see whatwe, ourselves, have to do under the circumstances.
Since conditions are and must remain such as we have described them, we shall forever continue to be what we have been and are, parasites, who are a burden to the rest of the population, and can never secure their favor. The fact that, as it seems, we can mix with the nations only in the smallest proportions, presents a further obstacle to the establishment of amicable relations. Therefore, we must see to it that the surplus, the unassimilable residue, is removed and elsewhere provided for. This duty can be incumbent upon no one but ourselves. In the Jews could be equally distributed among all the peoples of the earth, perhaps there would be no Jewish question. But this is not possible. Nay, more, there can be no doubt that an immigration of the Jews en masse into the
Another result of our experience is the recognition that the lamentable outcome of the emigration from Russia and Roumania is ascribable solely to the momentous fact that we were taken by it unawares; we had made no provision for the principal needs, a refuge and a systematic organization of the emigration. When thousands were seeking new homes we forgot to provide for that which no villager forgets when he desires to move—the small matter, forsooth, of a new and suitable dwelling.
most advanced states would be declined with emphasis
We say this with a heavy heart; but we must admit the truth. And this admission is the more important, inasmuch as it is only by realizing the truth that we can improve our position.
Moreover, it would be very unfortunate if we were not willing to profit by those results of our experience which have practical value. The most important of these results is the constantly growing conviction that we are nowhere at home, and that we finally must have a home, if not a country of our own.
If we would have a secure home, so that we may give up our endless life of wandering and rehabilitate our nation in our own eyes, and in the eyes of the world, we must, above all, not dream of restoring ancient Judea. We must not attach ourselves to the place where our political life was once violently interrupted and destroyed. The goal of our present endeavors must be not the “Holy Land,” but a land of our own. We need nothing but a large piece of land for our poor brothers; a piece of land which shall remain our property, from which no foreign master can expel us. Thither we will bring with us the most sacred possessions which we have saved from the shipwreck of our former fatherland, the God-idea and the Bible. It is only these which have made our old fatherland the Holy Land, and not Jerusalem or