identical with the Rabbinical section of Jewry, viz., in their love and attachment to the Holy Land, to them also their own land. Incidentally, I may mention that they were almost the very first who took up Arabic as the language of literary composition, and in so far compelled their adversaries to use the same language, and this contributed powerfully, though indirectly, to the rise of the most glorious part of Hebrew literature,. the Hebrew Arabic, which flourished close upon a thousand years in the East and in Spain, and formed a link of unity between the scattered sons of Israel through the Mohammedan Empire. What influence it has had also upon the rest of Jewry is not here the place to diseuss, but also, in this respect, Palestine was the very centre of Hebrew Mohammedan learning in the eighth and ninth centuries, and to the Karaites we owe the first example of a transcript of the Bible with Arabic characters, just as we owe to the Jews of Egypt the first transcript of the Bible into Greek letters. I do not wish, however, to be drawn away from the main object of this paper, and to dilate on those by-paths of Hebrew learning so fascinating for those who leave the highroad, and prefer to wander not quite aimlessly amid the shades of the huge forest of Hebrew literature, and cull a flower here and there that grows by the way. In Palestine we place the first Hebrew worker on medicine, the mysterious Assaf, in the tenth century. On this partly peaceful and partly stormy time, stormy so far as intellectual electricity and tension is concerned, for it never went beyond the fulmination of literary tracts, there broke the storm of the Crusaders, which wiped out many a community, and threw into the cauldron of devastation Karaite and Rabbinite alike, and reduced the number of Jews to a handful and their condition to a pitiable one. All the while a current of immigration from the Diaspora fed the dwindling population of Palestine. I do not dwell on solitary immiigrations of scholars and great men from Babylon and Egypt who settled in Palestine.
One great and luminous figure stands
out prominently at this very time in the person of Judah Halevi (1140), who sang his song of Zion on the ruins of the Temple, and vanished there, for, according to the legend, the Lord had taken him. And our great Maimuni followed, then, in the footsteps of Judah Halevi, and sought a first refuge in Palestine, then in Egypt, where, as it is well known, he became the medical adviser of Saladin; he sought afterwards his last resting-place in the land of his fathers (1204). It is wonderful that up to this day the graves of these great men, like that of Moses, remain unknown, for they were not to belong to one special spot; the whole of Palestine claims them, as they claim the whole of Palestine, as their own. When Jacob saw his vision, he was told the land that he was lying on would belong to him and to his descendants after him, and our sages explain that the whole of Erez Israel had been gathered under him on that occasion; and so it evidently was again in the case of Maimuni and Halevi.
The free entry of the Jews into Jerusalem was granted by Saladin immediately after the last of the Crusaders had departed from the place. Shortly before that period two noted Jewish travellers had been through the land, and commented on the very reduced number of inhabitants at that time living in Palestine. And yet these reports of Benjamin of Tudela, about 1173, and of Petachia (1187), shortly afterwards, as to the number of Jews, their wealth, their learning, their positions, compare very favorably with that of the rest of the inhabitants. If so many had been able to survive the storm of the Crusades, how many more must have been living previously to that in the country, and how strong must the attachment of the people have been that they persevered all the while through good and evil report? That their number must have been considerable we may infer incidentally from Rashi telling us that a Shaliah, or messenger-apostle from Palestine, had shown him the true intonations of some Biblical accents, and Ibn Ezra (1168) in the twelfth century also confers with the scholars and Massor-
