The Maccabaean · Vol. X, No. 4 · April 1906
126printed page
scan 10 of 54

of Tiberias and the Northern parts of Galilee, for a dense population enormous enough and independent enough to offer powerful armed assistance to the Persians in their fight against Heraklius, the Byzantine Emperor, in the year 614. In spite of this warlike undertaking, Israel dwelt in the tents of the Law, and the Massorah, or the fixing of the traditional text of the Bible, must be traced to the same centres in Galilee. From primitive and inefficient beginnings had grown up an elaborate system in the schools of the Scribes of Tiberias and other colleges, and there they collected and arranged the vast stores of information and annotations which accumulated during centuries round the text of the Bible. They show such a minute acquaintance with every detail of the Sacred Scriptures as can only be obtained by a life-long study by men who live in the midst of an appreciative population which knows how to make it easy for a scholar to devote his life to the Torah, even if it meant such minutiæ as a critical examination and study of each letter, dot and jot of the Bible. I need not repeat here that the text fixed by them is the standard text of our modern editions, and when Maimonides later on desired to write an exact copy of the Law he could find no better model than the perfect copy of Ben Asher, one of the heads of the Massoretic schools in Palestine. After the Bible and Prayer-Book comes the Paytan. Our liturgy received the first embellishment of a poetical nature in Palestine. Jose ben Jose, and above all Eleazar Kalir, whom I consider of Palestinian origin, and who may have lived at a much earlier date than has hitherto been assumed, marks the beginning of liturgical poetry. He also lays down permanent lines upon which the later liturgical poetry, to a large extent, has grown up in the East, as well as in the West. And, finally, a word about mysticism, the beginnings of religious philosophy, the attempts to solve the mystery of the creation, of life, of death, by means of speculation and meditation. Again I do not wish to trespass on your time, or dwell to long on this part of mental

activity, except to point out that the possibility of such a literature originating and growing, as it has grown very considerably, can only be explained by the fact of a population educated enough and varied enough in its qualities and occupations to facilitate abstract pursuits and mystical speculations. We have, on the one hand, Elisha B. Abuyah, and on the other hand the Sepher Yezirah, and other more mystical and metaphysical treatises, the details of which I spare you. This brings us down to the seventh or eigth century, immediately after the rise of the Mohammedan power and the establishment of the Caliphate in Babylon.

We are on the threshold of a great movement inside the Jewish nation, when philosophical doctrines and, perhaps, personal considerations play an important part in driving a wedge in the compact mass of Jewry. I am speaking of the Karaite movement. It starts in Babylon under the leadership of Anan, a reputed descendant of the house of David, and a competitor for the honor of Prince of the Exile. In a paper dealing with the various sects in Judaism, I intend to treat the manifold movements which have arisen from time to time, and there I intend to discuss also the inner bearings of this schism which focussed in one centre many scattered tendencies that had survived from olden times and which now joined their forces and fused into a combined attack on the traditional interpretations of the Law as expounded by the great schools of Babylon and Palestine. Ousted from Babylon, the larger mass of Karaites emigrated to Palestine, and there they formed very large communities in various places, notably the community of Jerusalem, known for a long time as the Abelim or the Mourners for Jerusalem.

Many a well-known writer arose from the midst of the Karaites in Palestine, and if I mention this fact here it is to show that they also sought their strength in living in the Holy Land amidst the old surroundings. However much they protested, more or less vigorously, against later oral tradition, in one point they felt themselves