new for the old was not a perfect solution, but that the new is in many ways inferior to the old, for the void created in the mind by the removal of the old, cannot be adequately filled with the new.
In such a case the new faction is likely to be subdivided into many and various sects. Those who are conscious of this void long for an "ideal" and seek for a means of satisfying their souls; and in their search they either advance too far or occasionally even go backwards. In both cases their want is not satisfied, for artificial ideals cannot fill the natural void for any length of time. Many, at last, in despair, accustom themselves to this void and seek no further for help.
As soon as the adherents of the old theory see the confusion in the camp of the new, they regain their courage; their hope is revived, the hope that in a short time the world will return to its old standpoint. As a rule, they are mistaken: generally these fluctuations forwards and backwards move society neither forwards nor backwards. They only bear witness that society needs a third moderate theory, a compromise between old and new, which should remove the undesirable but re-introduce the desirable elements which had been rashly laid aside. It should present both sides under a new aspect adapted to the new age and thus restore the balance between the “spiritual interests” which represent the heritage of the old, and those which were created by the new, but have already become the inalienable possession of the mind. Such a theory shows itself in course of time, as the consequence of the fluctuations mentioned. But its growth may be hastened or retarded according to the causes that produced it and the circumstances of life.
A complicated movement of this nature arose among our own people more than a century ago and has not yet reached its limit. From its progress during the last
few years the inference may be drawn that it is not far from the right path.
There were "moderate adherents of the negative" among the Jews of Western Europe even before the modern movement of enlightenment, which was brought about by Mendelssohn. But as they had nothing with which to fill the void, they did not form a separate sect, and they remained passive. When however, a new positive tendency grew up in the minds of a select few—the need of the right of citizenship and the belief in the possibility of its attainment through the adoption of European culture—the adherents of the negative immediately joined the representatives of the new positive theory. These, perhaps, were at first merely lovers of "the true, the good, and the beautiful," and did not dream that the negative might one day be attributed to them, and be dated from the German translation of the Bible. Hence these two parties formed a confederation, and with shouts of exaltation and victory, mercilessly proceeded to destroy the bulwarks of the Jewish nation. When they were victorious or at any rate believed that they were, critics arose who found deficiencies in their positive ideal, but even more in their negative. For they had not confined their work of destruction merely to obsolete views of observance, but had even attacked the very existence and unity of the people. Thereupon these critics experienced a spiritual void and sought for a means of filling it. They believed they had found it: some in magnificent temples, with their endless, empty sermons, others, in this case the most prominent among them, found it in the new being which they had created and styled in a manner befitting its importance "the science of Judaism."
In works devoted to this science, a very curious fact comes under our observation. The preface is full of weighty contents displaying sacred love for the Jewish nation and its literature, while the book itself—the “science” written to bear out the preface— merely consists of trivial points of detail