The Maccabaean · Vol. X, No. 3 · March 1906
102printed page
scan 26 of 52
102
THE MACCABAEAN

supported the present Conservative Government. Of the three since elected onecomes into the same category and in addition Mr. Wolff is a member of the Conservative party.

The following are the twelve present Jewish members of Parliament with their constituencies. The first eight are supporters of the Government, the remainder are in opposition. Benjamin L. Cohen (East Is-lington), Capt. H. M. Jessel (South St. Pancras), Col. F. A. Lucas (Lowestoft), H. H. Marks (Thanet), the Hon. L. W. Rothschild (South Bucks), Sir Harry Samuel (Limehouse), Sir Edward Sassoon (Hythe), Louis Sinclair (Romford), Rufus Isaacs, K. C. (Reading), Maurice Levy (Leicestershire), and Stuart M. Samuel (Whitechapel). Political parties in England are, or have been until recently, very sharply divided. Mr. Chamberlain's proposals have led to some disintegration, but hitherto the Jewish members of Parliament have been unaffected. Mr. Chamberlain has by no means converted the whole of the Conservative Party to his views, and prominent among the stalwart Conservative Free-Traders appears more than one Jewish name. In the House, however, the Jewish Conservatives all remain loyal, and despite the alleged Free-Trade leanings of some of them, the Government can with safety rely upon their votes. Ignoring votes, however, which notoriously often do not represent opinions, we may classify the Jewish contingent in respect of Mr. Chamberlain's proposals. The four Liberal members are consistent and determined Free-Traders. On the same side array themselves Mr. Cohen and the Hon. L. W. Rothschild, although neither has shown himself staunch in support of the principles of Cobden and Bright. In the next class stand Capt. Jessel and Sir Edward Sassoon. They are among the indeterminate, committed definitely to no opinion, waiting apparently to see which way the cat jumps. Sir Harry Samuel, Col. Lucas,

A topic on which the Jewish representation is divided not in accordance with parties is that of Alien Immigration. In the new session the chief measure will deal with that topic. The new bill, it is generally believed, will be by no means so drastic as that of last year. Consequently it is difficult to foretell the attitude of Jewish members towards it. In England all are in favour of legislation for the exclusion of criminal and diseased aliens, and if the Government had accepted a measure to that effect last year, it would have received universal support. It is only when further restrictions are attempted that divisions show themselves and these divisions by no means follow party lines. On the motion for the second reading of last year's bill three Jewish members voted against the measure, two in favor of it, and five abstained from voting. The three opponents were Messrs. Maurice Levy, Herbert Samuel, and Stuart Samuel. The two supporters were Sir Harry Samuel and Colonel Lucas. The Hon. Walter Rothschild, Sir Edward Sassoon, Capt. Jessel, Messrs. B. L. Cohen and Louis Sinclair abstained. In subsequent divisions the bill was also supported by Mr. Sinclair and opposed by Mr. Rothschild. These votes, however, do not represent the whole of the Jewish attitude towards the bill. Sir Harry Samuel and Mr. Sinclair are among the strongest advocates for exclusion and have taken a very prominent part in the campaign that preceded the attempt at legislation. Of the members who have been elected since the measure was before the House Mr. Marks supports the exclusion policy as strongly as it is opposed by Mr. Isaacs.

Messrs. Marks and Sinclair have more courage if less discretion. They have ranged themselves definitely on the side of Tariff Reform. They have boldly proclaimed themselves converts to neo-protectionism and have thereby seriously endangered their seats.

Although in numbers the Jewish repre.