The Maccabaean · Vol. X, No. 3 · March 1906
96printed page
scan 20 of 52

to justify their unfavorable attitude by a mass of accusations which, on closer examination, prove to be baseless or negligible. He, however, who desires to be unbiased, who does not desire to judge and interpret the affairs of this world according to the principles of an Utopian Arcadia, but would merely ascertain and explain them in order to reach a conclusion of practical value, will not make either of the parties seriously responsible for the antagonism described. To the Jews, however, in whom we are chiefly interested, he will say: "You certainly are a foolish and contemptible people! You are foolish, because you stand awkwardly by and expect of human nature something which it has always lacked—humanity. You are contemptible, because you have no real self-love and no national self-respect."

National self-respect! Where can we get it? It is truly the greatest misfortune of our race that we do not constitute a nation; that we are merely Jews. We are a flock scattered over the whole face of the earth, without a shepherd to protect us and gather us together. Under the most favorable circumstances we reach the rank of goats, which are mated in Russia with racehorses. And that is the highest goal of our ambition!

It is true that our dear protectors have always taken good care that we should never get out of breath and recover our self-respect. As individual Jews, but not as a Jewish nation, we have carried on for centuries the hard and unequal struggle for existence. In isolation each separate individual had to waste his genius and his energy for a little oxygen and a morsel of bread, moistened with tears. In this hopeless struggle we did not succumb. We waged the most glorious of all partisan struggles with all the peoples of the earth, who with one accord, desired to exterminate us. But the war we have waged—and God knows how long we shall continue to wage it— has not been for a fatherland, but for the

wretched maintenance of millions of "Jew peddlers."

If all the peoples of the earth were not able to blot out our existence, they were nevertheless able to destroy in us the feeling of our national independence. And as for ourselves we look on with fatalistic indifference when in many a land we are refused a recognition which would not lightly be denied to Zulus. In the Dispersion we maintained our individual life, and proved our power of resistance, but we lost the common bond of our national consciousness. Seeking to maintain our material existence, we were constrained only too often to forget our moral dignity. We did not see that on account of tactics unworthy of us, which we were forced to adopt, we sank still lower in the eyes of our opponents, that we were only the more exposed to humiliating contempt and outlawry, which have finally become our baleful heritage. In the wide, wide world there was no place for us. We prayed only for a little place anywhere to lay our weary head to rest; and so, by lessening our claims, we gradually lessened as well our dignity, which was effaced in our own and others' eyes until it became unrecognizable. We were the shuttlecock which the peoples tossed in turn to one another. The cruel game was equally amusing whether we were caught or thrown, and was enjoyed all the more, the more elastic and yielding our national respect became in the hands of the peoples. Under such circumstances, how could there be any question of national self-determination, of a free, active development of our national force or of our native genius?

We may note, in passing, that our enemies, in order to prove our inferiority, have not failed to make capital of this last trait, which, though in a measure borne out by facts, is at bottom altogether irrelevant. One would think that men of genius were as plentiful among our opponents as blackberries in August. Poor creatures! They