The Maccabaean · Vol. X, No. 3 · March 1906
95printed page
scan 19 of 52
95
THE MACCABAEAN

The legal emancipation of the Jews is the crowning achievement of our century. But legal emancipation is not social emancipation, and with the proclamation of the former the Jews are still far from being emancipated from their exceptional social position.

The emancipation of the Jews naturally finds its justification in the fact that it will always be considered to have been a postulate of logic, of law, and of enlightened self-interest. It can never be regarded as a spontaneous expression of human feeling. Far from owing its origin to the spontaneous feeling of the peoples, it is never a matter of course; and it has never yet taken such deep root that further discussion of it becomes unnecessary. In any event, whether emancipation was undertaken from spontaneous impulse or from conscious motives, it remains a rich gift, a splendid alms, willingly or unwillingly flung to the poor, humble beggars whom no one, however, cares to shelter, because a homeless, wandering beggar wins confidence or sympathy from none. The Jew is not permitted to forget that the daily bread of civil rights must be given him. The stigma attached to this people, which forces an unenviable isolation among the nations upon it, cannot be removed by any sort of official emancipation, as long as this people produces in accordance with its nature vagrant nomads., as long as it cannot give a satisfactory account of whence it comes and whither it goes, as long as the Jews themselves prefer not to speak in Aryan society of their Semitic descent, and prefer not to be reminded of it. as long as they are persecuted, tolerated, protected, emancipated.

This degrading dependence of the eternally alien Jew upon the non-Jew is reenforced by another factor, making a fusion of the Jews with the original inhabitants of a land absolutely impossible. In the great struggle for existence, civilized peoples readily submit to laws which help to

change their struggle into a peaceful competition, a noble emulation. Even in this case the peoples usually make a distinction between the native and the foreigner, the first, of course, always being given the preference. Now, if this distinction is drawn even against the foreigner of equal birth, how harshly is it insisted upon, in reference to the eternally alien Jew? With what irritation the beggar must be regarded who dares to cast longing glances upon a land, the home of others, as upon a beloved woman guarded by distrustful relatives! And if he nevertheless prospers, and succeeds in plucking a flower here and there from its soil, woe to the ill-fated man! Let him not complain if he experiences what the Jews in Spain and Russia have experienced.

This natural antagonism is the basis of the untold number of reciprocal misunderstandings and accusations and reproaches which both parties rightfully or wrongfully cast at each other. Thus the Jews, instead of realizing their own position and adopting a rational line of conduct, appeal to eternal justice, and fondly imagine that the appeal will have some effect. On the other hand, the non-Jews, instead of relying simply upon their superior force and holding fast to their historical and actual standpoint—the standpoint of the stronger—try

The Jews, moreover, do not suffer onlywhen they achieve distinguished success.Wherever they are congregated in largemasses, they must, by their very numbers,have a certain advantage in competitionwith the non-Jewish population. In thewestern provinces of Russia we behold theJews herded together, eking out a wretchedexistence in the most dreadful destitution.Nevertheless, complaints of the exploitationpracticed by the Jews never cease.

To sum up what has been said, for the living, the Jew is a dead man, for the natives an alien and a vagrant, for property-holders a beggar, for the poor an exploiter and a millionaire, for patriots a man without a country, for all classes a hated rival.