The Maccabaean · Vol. X, No. 3 · March 1906
92printed page
scan 16 of 52
92
THE MACCABARAN

only in so remote a future that the admission of the Jewish people into the category of the other nations seems illusory. They lack most of those attributes which are the hall-marks of a nation. They lack that characteristic national life which is inconceivable without a common language, common customs, and a common land. The Jewish people have no fatherland of their own, though many motherlands; they have no rallying point, no center of gravity, no government of their own, no accredited representatives. They are everywhere in evidence, and nowhere at home. The nations have never to deal with a Jewish nation, but always with mere Jews. The Jews are not a nation, because they lack a certain distinctive national character, possessed by every other nation, a character which is determined by living together in one country, under one government. It was clearly impossible for this national character to be developed in the Dispersion; the Jews seem rather to have lost every memory of their former home. Thanks to their ready adaptability, they have all the more easily acquired the alien traits of the people among whom their fate cast them. Moreover, to please their protectors, they not seldom divested themselves of their traditional individuality. They acquired, or persuaded themselves that they had acquired, certain cosmopolitan tendencies which could appeal to others no more than they could satisfy the Jews themselves.

In seeking to fuse with other peoples, they wilfully renounced, to a certain extent, their own nationality. Nowhere, however, did they succeed in obtaining from their fellow-citizens recognition as native-born citizens of equal rank.

The strongest fact, however, operating to prevent the Jews from striving after an independent national existence is the fact that they feel no need for such an existence. Not only do they feel no need for it, but they even deny the reasonableness of such a need.

In a sick person the absence of desire for food and drink is a very serious symptom. It is not always possible to cure him of this fateful loss of appetite. And even if his appetite is restored, it is still a question whether he will be able to assimilate food, even though he desires it.

The Jews are in the sad position of such a patient. We must discuss this most important point with all possible precision. We must prove that the misfortunes of the Jews are due, above all, to their lack of desire for national independence; and that this desire must be evoked and maintained in time if they do not wish to be exposed forever to disgraceful existence—in a word, we must prove that they must become a nation.

In the apparently insignificant circumstance, that the Jews are not considered an independent nation by the other peoples, lies, in part, the secret of their anomalous position and of their endless misery. The mere fact of belonging to this people constitutes an indelible stigma, repellent to non-Jews, and painful to the Jews themselves. Nevertheless, this phenomenon has its basis deep down in the nature of man.

Among the living nations of the earth the Jews occupy the position of a nation long since dead. With the loss of their fatherland, the Jewish people lost their independence, and fell into a decay which is not compatible with existence as an integral, living organism. The state, crushed under the weight of the Roman rule, disappeared from before the eyes of the nations.. But after the Jewish people had given up their existence as an actual state, as a political entity, they could nevertheless not succumb to total destruction—they did not cease to exist spiritually as a nation. The world saw in this people the uncanny form of one of the dead walking among the living. This ghostlike apparition of a people without unity or organization, without land or other bond of union, no longer alive, and yet moving about among the living,—this