The Maccabaean · Vol. X, No. 2 · February 1906
42printed page
scan 6 of 52
Facsimile · scan 6 of 52
Scan of p. 42
Text · transcribed from the scan

in the Jewish history of these countries. What we are told about them up to the end of the tenth century, concerns the fate of the Jews living there; after the foundation of the Talmud schools, there begins a history of Judaism and of Jewish culture. R. Hushiel, R. Moses, and R. Elkanan ben Shemariah are not merely the founders of Talmudic learning in the lands of their adoption, they are also the originators of Jewish culture there.

The characteristics of the Rabbi as architect and exponent of Jewish culture makes it obvious that we are here not concerned with the rabbinical institution of modern times. The rabbi of centuries gone by called himself neither disciple of the prophets, nor successor to the priests, nor pastor, nor aught resembling these epithets. He was anything but what we are at present in the habit of understanding by the term rabbi. He was neither an official of the congregation, nor its minister. His modesty forbade the one, his pride the other. He was master over none but himself, and he was servant to none but his God. Still less may we conceive of the rabbi of yore as the preacher, the orator of the synagogue. In the good old times, every Jew considered himself at home in the synagogue, and there was no need to delegate the talking to one particularly privileged person. There was no sphere of activity for a specialist who says the prayers for the rest of the worshippers, at a time in which every single member of the congregation was an eager participant in the Divine service, not to mention the fact that rabbinic Judaism lays particular stress upon the dogma of the direct connection between God and man, and will not brook the intervention of a mediator between the Most High and the meanest of His human creatures. In short, the rabbinical profession as a profession is of comparatively recent growth. In the olden days, rabbis were recruited from all classes of society. State officials and men in the humblest walks of

life, physicians, astronomers, tradesmen, and artisans, they all vied with one another in the vast audience-chamber of rabbinical literature, and there they and their opinions all received equal consideration. "The student of the Torah who devotes himself to its investigations in order to escape the duty of toil and self-support, desecrates the honor of God; he disgraces the Torah, extinguishes the light of faith, brings an evil fate down upon himself, and forfeits his portion in the world to come." These expressions, it should be said, are not excerpted from a collection of ethical sayings, but are quoted from a rabbinical code of laws, and they explain, from an economic point of view, why a rabbinical profession could not develop in former days.

What is it that made the Jewish scholar of the Middle Ages the important factor he actually was in the spiritual life of his people? The reply to this question is of vital interest, and not alone to those of us to whom Jewish culture is more than an idle word. Even he who does not see his ideal in the rabbi of the Middle Ages, does well to examine his radiant figure and try to define and grasp its harmonious proportions. The old rabbinical ideal is in very truth superseded only when the best it offers can be replaced by something better. To shove it aside contemptuously is not to know it. Who knows it, cannot but admit how much is to be learned from it, and he will learn from it, not as from an adversary, but as from a friend, and what he learns from it, so far from fettering his modernity, will but enhance it.

I have chosen the inner and outer life of the rabbinical student as my subject, because I hold that a consideration of it will enable us to reply to the question as to what it is that gave the Jewish scholar his peculiarly important place in the spiritual economy of his nation.

The Jews were the first people to institute compulsory education. Very few illiterates could be found among them so long