ments advanced by the spirit of sculpture and the spirit of learning in defense of the artistic and the scholastic life. The spirit of learning wins Lucian for the life of the scholar by the final contention that “Even if he became as great as Phidias and Polycletus, he would still be a menial working with his hands.”
Men seldom stop to calculate the price paid for the things that are enjoyed, or to discover who exactly paid the price. There are few more valuable treasures in the world than the philosophy, the art and the literature of the Greeks. But the pleasure these yield must be considerably diminished wherever there is a lively realization of the price paid for their production and the condition of the price-payers. Aristotle in his “Meaphysics” refers the origin of science to Egypt where alone there was a large leisured class—the priests. But it was the bondage of the lower castes that gave to the priests their leisure, and it was slavery, peculiarly detestable in those conditions, that gave to the genial Greeks their leisure to cultivate the arts and sciences. The Greek policy was based entirely upon the labor of enslaved humanity.
The lecturer proceeded to demonstrate that wherever slavery prevails, as it prevailed in Hellas, it is impossible that there should exist any pure conception of morality. The Hellenes were frankly immoral. The wife was almost devoid of rights besent, and remained through her life the ward of father or husband, brother or son, and was relegated to the society of slaves. Only when they were outcasts (Aspasias and Theodotas) did women receive and intellectual consideration. Compare all this for a moment with the attitude of the Jewish sages, who were ever prepared, like Akiba, to lay down in homage the achievements of their lives at the feet of wife or mother, declaring all to be the fruit of her hands and the product of her influence. The Jews, with their tradition that it was only through the merit of women that sal-
vation had come or would come, with their aspirations to purity as the firts stage of the soul-life, with their iron-bound regulations. enforcing purity and continence even within the sphere of married life, could not but have despised the Greek and regarded him as living at the brute level. "Ye can claim the name 'man,' but they cannot claim the name 'man.'"
Hellenic immorality culminated in a black leprosy of unnameable bestiality which the influence of Judaism made inconceivable for the man of to-day. To this leprosy, the prevalent slavery, the low condition of pure womanhood, and in a special degree, the constant exposure in gymnasia and palaestrae contributed. Even the Romans expressed their utter horror at Hellenic moral degradation. Cicero and Horace stigmatise excess of intemperance and debauchery as "Hellenic," and Pliny calls the Greek the inventor of every vice.
The lecturer declared that there was no occasion for extreme surprise at the condition of Hellas, for no stream of water can rise above its source and no nation above the level of its gods. Religious life must be an imitation of the gods worshipped.
Doubtless many pure and beautiful conceptions were hypostatised, personified and deified and enthroned in the Grecian Heaven. But Polytheism at its best remains utterly immoral. Even when the gods represent the purest moral powers, the consequences are disastrous. Virtue must be one, or it ceases to be a virtue. If you deify Justice and deify Mercy, then you separate one from the other. But Justice without Mercy is cruel rigor, and Mercy without Justice is culpable weakness. If you deify Love and deify Purity, then you separate the one from the other. But Love without Purity is bestiality, and Purity without Love is selfish isolation. But in the Greek Heaven there were also many impure conceptions and unclean fancies. Homer and Hesiod were the only univer-
